Islamorada Fish Company

Reviews

• RC

  Ron Crowell

  3 days ago
  3.0
  The food was satisfactory. At $20 a plate, I'd expect it to look a little fancy. The portions are not what you'd expect either. The experience was like they had given up on being a 5 star, and turned into a dive bar. I'd rather go somewhere else after shopping at Bass Pro shops.
• JJ

  J

  Sep 2, 2026
  4.0
  The fish and chips were my choice for the day. The plate comes with two very large deep fried fillets and a pile of fries. I found the fish crispy on the outside and soft and flakey on the inside. The Fried Pickles are a tastey appetizer to start a lunch or dinner. The pickles are fried medium crisp on the outdide and dill tangy on the inside, and a bunch of them come in the bowl, perfect for sharing. The pickle dipping sauce is tastey too, though the fried pickles stand tall on their own. Next time I am in, I plan to do an all appetizer sharable meal since this place has so many appetizers. The sliders really sounded great. Today's server, Brian, did an outstanding job of taking care of us today.
• RR

  Road_Glider

  Aug 27, 2026
  5.0
  Like many others I stopped in to take a load off and enjoy the atmosphere at Isla Morada. Food and beer hit the spot for a chill afternoon trying to wait out the wife and her ever eternal rabbit hole of shopping. Fortunately I had Brian to help me through! Brian was 5 stars across the board. Attentive, warm and courteous. Instant pals man! So much so he earned Isa Morada bumped Isla Morada to a 5 star experience. Thank you to Brian and Bass Pro for an awesome afternoon for the fellas. Till next time! 🔥
• IG

  Izadora Gutierrez

  Aug 8, 2026
  5.0
  We had a great experience! Hona was very professional, friendly, and helpful. We truly appreciate the great service and would definitely recommend him to others!
• BH

  By HSThassan

  Aug 2, 2026
  2.0
  Didn’t like their fish and chips It was totally a scam to make it in a way that it looks big fillets of fish however it was all hard crust with few bites of fish I had tried their fish and chips before which was absolutely delicious This time very disappointed Please keep the recipe same Otherwise it drops the quality and taste Thank you Hope you will bring back the original taste