As a seasoned solo traveler, I weigh service most heavily when scoring a hotel, and the InterContinental Barclay earns its five stars on that front.
Arrival: Check-in was the one weak spot. As an IHG Platinum member, I received a dry welcome and minimal details about what to expect, and when I asked a simple question, the response was defensive. That said, she was the only rude person I encountered during my entire stay, which is an achievement in itself in NYC, so one offense doesn't change my score.
Staff: The bellmen had the best vibe and energy of anyone, which matters since they're the first people you meet when you walk in. My bags were never brought to my room as promised, though they did apologize. The outdoor valet team was kind and helpful with directions. The concierge was fine, but felt a bit locked away in their room. I understand they have work to do, so a greeter stationed near the entrance to answer quick questions might help. I also loved the cultural diversity of the staff, which reflects the melting pot that is NYC and deserves to be celebrated.
Room: The cleaning staff are on point. My room was spotless, spacious and well maintained, and if every room is as consistent as mine, I doubt anyone would be unhappy with any room type. The king bed and bedding were super comfortable, temperature adjustment was easy, and the bathroom was functional with okay water pressure and temperature. The towels have a unique, fitting design but are well past their life expectancy. The complimentary chocolate mousse is a nice gesture, though it had an unexpected aftertaste. Bring your reusable bottle, too: water refill stations are on even floors, and the water on 12 was clean, cold and filtered.
Buffet: Quintessential and worth it. The service was amazing, the food diverse (American staples alongside duck dumplings and congee), everything was well maintained, and there are kid-friendly options.
Fitness center: I didn't visit, so I can't comment, but it's certainly a necessity.
Suggestions: To evolve this into a complete luxury experience that's the envy of other hotel brands, the service and hospitality are already there. I'd suggest:
- Letting guests text hotel staff directly, without entering a phone number and waiting to be contacted
- Replacing the towels
- Soundproofing the rooms. The walls are noticeably thin, like a 3-star hotel, even with reasonably quiet guests
- Making sure the toiletries suit all skin types. The current fragrance is the most accommodating unisex scent I've encountered across all the hotel brands I've stayed with
Don't add too many bells and whistles. Focus on preserving the beautiful historic architecture and the welcoming, diverse experience you already have.
Bottom line: A quintessential traditional hotel stay with excellent service, and a diamond in the rough but lovable NYC.