East Islip Jewelers

Reviews

• KP

  Kevin Pristera

  4 days ago
  5.0
  Amazing staff I had a ring designed from scratch they made it a super easy process and my fiancé is in love with her dream ring
• CD

  Cristine Davis

  May 10, 2026
  5.0
  A heartfelt thank you to Vanessa and this family run establishment for helping make my Mother’s Day over the top special. I felt secure knowing my jewelry was safe in their hands and the turn around to complete my finished piece was super quick. Now i proudly show off my new diamond ring setting with the upmost pride! Thank you all
• MG

  Mary Gilmore

  Apr 28, 2026
  5.0
  The two rings that I had resized turned out absolutely beautiful they fit so well that I forget that I'm wearing them these rings are over 30 years old and have a great deal of meaning to me personally but more so I have new memories of them that I can share every single day from this time on thank you so much for a beautiful job done Mary Gilmore 🥰 just came back from having a battery replaced in an old $6 watch and never did you laugh at the fact that the battery cost more than the watch what matters the most is that I have a new watch to wear and not worry about thank you so much for being a good jeweler greatly appreciated love Mary Gilmore I'll be back 🥰🫤
• MG

  Michael Gerner

  Apr 23, 2026
  5.0
  While searching for a pre-owned Rolex Day-Date, I came across East Islip Jewelers Ad, and reached to Mr. G. Well, I can’t say enough about the professionalism and courtesy he demonstrated during my first call to his shop. He answered every question, sent me every picture I requested, in the end we agreed to a price of the year for me! I agreed to purchase and he sent it overnight! This was a very positive experience working with Mr. G, and I would be happy to buy from him again.
• EE

  erin escobar

  Apr 22, 2026
  5.0
  I cannot recommend East Islip jewelers enough. They are great for repairs Quick and convenient. They sized my fiancé’s ring for a great price. I lost one of my diamonds in my engagement ring recently lucky enough to find it at my house. They reset it for me and had it ready in one day once again for a very reasonable price. I haven’t purchased any jewelry directly from them But I definitely will in the future. Very clean and straightforward. If you’re looking for a jeweler to take care of your jewelry & or to purchase from Look no further