Plato's Closet buys and sells gently used clothing, shoes, sneakers, accessories and athletic wear for teens and young adults in East Amherst. Sell styles you no longer wear for cash on the spot, or shop thrifted, secondhand, and resale fashion, including trendy, brand-name styles for less. With 500+ independently owned and operated locations across the U.S. and Canada, fresh inventory arriving daily, Plato's Closet makes thrifting easy, affordable, and more sustainable.
large location so i like the selection and i think they are more likely than west seneca to buy ur stuff because of that. the people are usually nice and there is a bathroom which i appreciate
LH
Lisa Hanson
Aug 4, 2026
3.0
Place only works if you have money to buy expensive clothing and kids that don't play or wrinkle there clothes. You can't shop at Walmart or target to go there with brand new clothes to get money bc you won't. High end only buy if you want to buy some high end clothes that have been worn the place is the place. Some stuff to me is overpriced for it being used.
KF
Kara Faller
Jul 27, 2026
1.0
I would give this place 0stars if it was an option for selling you are just better off donating to someone who needs it!!! I took my daughters stuff to sell they said they are only taking work out clothes sweatshirts and sweaters which is fine they took two things for 6.75 ? One was an Ugg sweatshirt over 100$ and they offer 3$ are you kidding and didn’t even take a nice pair of lululemon leggings what a waste of of time and gas this place is disgusting and should stop saying they will offer you cash more like pennies!!! Have a yard sell you will get more money lol…. Expensive brand name clothes and didn’t take but two things shame on you will never shop nor sell ever again!
SD
sisi diaz
May 15, 2026
1.0
Do not try to sell ur clothes here. There way to picky and try to give everything back for “deconditioning”. I checked my clothes before trying to sell them and had 0 stains and very minimal pilling but complained all my clothes had it. Not to mention, I was giving them away expensive, name brand items with the tag still on while the store was full of complete garbage. I wasn’t expecting to get a lot of money in the first place and that wasn’t the reason why I went but for pretty much all my stuff to be returned is upsetting.
DG
Dana Gregory
May 4, 2026
5.0
Wide variety, tiny bit pricey but really organized and easy to find clothes.
This information is certified by Plato's Closet and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified August 30, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: