West by God CoalFired Pizza

Reviews

• EB

  Erica Bullard

  2 days ago
  5.0
  We ate as a family. This was the cheapest meal we’ve had in the area. With 5 kids, everyone enjoyed it! My husband really liked sampling the wall of beer on tap and trying different kinds. The menu has changed slightly from what I had previewed online before going. Tuesday is apparently half priced pizza! And they offer a military discount!
• NG

  Nicole Gordon

  5 days ago
  5.0
  LISTEN! We’re from Youngstown Ohio home of the BrierHill pizza, our town is know for our love of pizza and this place didn’t miss what so ever. Pizza, fries, and wings all on point. Atmosphere and staff welcoming and friendly. Will be back on our next visit to the area.
• BK

  bailey ketterer

  Aug 20, 2026
  5.0
  Shocked to find pizza of this quality near the Smoky Mountains of all places. I've had some of the best pizzas in the world at Sally's, Frank Pepe's, and more with my favorite being Zuppardi's. We had an Uber eats delivery from here, warmed the pizza in the oven probably 2 hours after it was made, and it was up there with some of the best in CT. Top 5 pizzas in my life, we will pivot and make a destination out of this place during our trip.
• JW

  Jennifer Wadsworth

  Aug 19, 2026
  5.0
  This place is fantastic. The pizza….off the chain. The axe throwing….so much fun. We played two rounds at 30 minutes each. Zach…the perfect host. We got the Little Thrillbilly Trio. This is any 12” pizza, 4 wings and fries. Perfect for two people. The 1863 pizza is really good and the wings were perfect and zesty. I think we got the hot honey. My husband also tried the onion rings and said they were really good. Everyone there was so nice. We really enjoyed talking to Zach. So personable. Go, even if it is just for the pizza. You won’t regret it.
• MC

  Matthew Coom

  Aug 16, 2026
  3.0
  Stopped in on our way home from Gatlinburg. The staff was amazing and really good with our kids. I really enjoyed the beer that they had on tap. Restrooms were spotless and well kept. I gave them a three because I went there for Pizza and the Pizza was subpar. The only thing that was good was the crust. The sauce didn’t really have flavor and the cheese was non existent. With the pizza having skimpy toppings and not all that great flavor the prices are ridiculous. I’d rather bring my business to Gondoliers. We sat right in front of the window and the chef wasn’t using anything to portion control. So maybe he wasn’t feeling very generous that day.

Frequently Asked Questions About West by God CoalFired Pizza