BT
Billy Thornton
2 days ago
Had dinner at your restaurant August 28th. The food was great, We ate at the bar, and really enjoyed getting to know Toni and Brandy. The food was outstanding and we enjoyed our evening so much we returned the following night. Another enjoyable evening. Great food, great service. We think Toni and Brandy are certainly a asset to your restaurant. Our compliments to your chef and staff.
We visit Hilton Head from New Jerseg every year, and Alexander's is always our favorite restaurant. We make it our tradition to dine there on our last night as a perfect way to end our vacation. Jill, the hostess, was warm, welcoming, and friendly from the moment we arrived. Our server, Michelle, provided excellent service and made the evening even more enjoyable. The food was outstanding from start to finish - the appetizer (crab cakes), entrees (prime rib - my favorite & halibut special), and desert (peanut butter and key lime pies) were all delicious. We look forward to returning every year!
Went for wife’s Birthday this week and let me tell you I was pleasantly surprised. It is the best meal I have had in a long while. I live on island and have tried the majority of restaurants, but this meal was definitely above all others I’ve had. They definitely picked up a frequent visitor as we will continue to come back. I must say it was not only the meal. The service all around. From entering the door to our fantastic waitress. It was a wonderful evening experience all around. Well done Alexanders. We will see you in the near future again!
NJ
Noelle Jaen
Aug 18, 2026
We dined here for my birthday for the first time last night and everything exceeded our expectations. We couldn’t have been more impressed. From the moment we walked in, the service was phenomenal. Every staff member, from the hostess to our waitress, made us feel welcome and well cared for. We enjoyed cocktails, a beautifully presented shrimp cocktail appetizer, and the evening’s specials the lobster tails for me and the mahi for my husband. Everything was cooked to perfection and absolutely delicious. Our waitress was incredibly kind and to make my birthday evening even more memorable she surprised me with a delicious chocolate dessert and brought my husband a slice of their key lime pie. Both desserts were fabulous! As locals, we’re always excited to find a restaurant that delivers such an exceptional dining experience. We will definitely be returning often and highly recommended to others.
OJ
Oanya Jennings
Aug 16, 2026
Tonight was our 18th anniversary and we spur of the moment decided to come here to Alexander’s.. we have been to Hilton head so many times but have never stopped in. So happy we did, Michelle was our waitress and she was great.. the hostess was wonderful as well. We enjoyed telling Michelle all about our trip today on our boating adventures. The food was wonderful, we had lobster and seafood pasta. The sauces were so yummy, the chef is very amazing. We are picky seafood lovers and this was the top of our list from the 5 days of being here. Not many on the island have crème brûlée.. so I was so happy when it was on the menu. They brought it out with a happy anniversary chocolate.. it was Perfectly prepared. The atmosphere was nice we were seated next to a water view which was an unexpected treat. Thanks for making our
Anniversary dinner perfect. 🤩 hubby ate half the dessert before I could snap a pic 😅