Sarah's on Central

Reviews

• SS

  Sue S

  May 10, 2026
  5.0
  We ate here on Mother's Day and only had about a 15-minute wait. It was busy, the service was friendly and efficient, the food was amazing. They offered free Sangria to the ladies for a Mother's Day special treat. We got the breakfast burrito, biscuits & gravy, and the chicken fried steak. Everything was delicious.
• SS

  Stefanie S

  May 5, 2026
  5.0
  Sarah's on Central is a must in historic downtown Eureka! There was a bit of a wait on a Saturday at lunchtime, but it was totally reasonable. The atmosphere is quaint and inviting, and the service was fantastic. Highly recommend the Cafe Provincial salad—easily one of the best salads I’ve ever had! My husband also loved their fish tacos. And don’t skip the bakery counter. We tried the blueberry pancake balls, a gooey butter square, and the cookie dough pie, and they were all incredible. Definitely a place we'll be coming back to!
• TE

  Tracie Eakin

  Apr 29, 2026
  1.0
  Terrible service. We travel a lot and try to visit small, local diners. The food was just ok here. The service needs a real overhaul. If you have to flag down a waiter, any waiter, to get your check, in a building where you can see 3-4 waiters, there is a problem. All these waiters could see us. They just didn’t check on us at all which lead to us having to flag a waiter down. Again, terrible service. Don’t bother coming here, there are several other places that look nice. Whatever service you get at other places won’t be as bad as this.
• KM

  Kelly McIntosh

  Apr 18, 2026
  3.0
  It was roughly 5:45 when we arrived. Not busy. We stood at the door 15 minutes as servers walked past and standing by the bakery counter before anyone talked to us. We were put off but I really wanted to try the Kung Foo Bloody Mary. When finally seated it was another 15 minutes just for my husband's basic bloody Mary. I knew mine was a meal on top so i expected it to take longer. We ordered the Walleye so excited to try it to be served cold fish 😌 our server never really came back and I had to go find her to get another drink 🍸 both plates were full of food hardly touched. Server comes back and says to go boxes? What? No that was a sign it was terrible. She never asked! We didn't say anything and paid $122.00 for terrible food and service. I did however love the Kung Foo Bloody Mary its dinner ans a drink $33.00 for it!
• CP

  Connie P

  Apr 16, 2026
  5.0
  Easy in as you park right in front. It was crowded on a nice spring day. The staff was friendly the food was good and they sell baked goods. They serve alcohol, also. I would go back, for sure!

Frequently Asked Questions About Sarah's on Central