Islamorada Fish Company

Reviews

• CS

  Carlos Simon

  2 days ago
  5.0
  Our server was Natilie. This is the 2nd time she has served us and each time she has demonstrated a caring, positive, and sincere attitude. It was a pleasure to deal with her. She is very pleasant in a genuine way. We wish every dining experience we have could be as enjoyable as she has made this one. She's a real treasure. I hope you appreciate her as much as we do.
• SS

  Sara

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Our server Natilie was awesome. She stepped in and took our order. She was fast and very efficient and checked in on us to see how our meal was. On the other hand when we were first seated and there was confusion on who was our server- the bartender- who had a table across from us - could see us looking around and instead of coming over to us or get someone wait on - she just ignored us. I would definitely come back.
• CH

  Carmen Hernandez

  3 days ago
  5.0
  We had a great experience at Islamorada Fish Company. We started with the wahoo dip, and it was absolutely delicious definitely a standout appetizer. For our main meals, I ordered the fried mahi mahi sandwich, and it was fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. My hubby ordered the Reuben grouper sandwich, and it was tasty and very well prepared. The Bimini bread they served was warm, soft, and honestly unforgettable. Our server, Natalie, was fantastic super attentive, friendly, and made sure we had everything we needed throughout the meal. Overall, great food, great service, and a relaxed, enjoyable atmosphere. We’ll definitely be back.
• CC

  CoolJul

  May 11, 2026
  2.0
  I had the famous fish sandwich. Fish was over cooked and had no seasoning. My husband had the fried shrimp they were over cooked as well. I ordered a cocktail and the server forgot to put the order in. When I asked him where my drink was he said "oh I forgot, do you still want it". When the manager came around to each table asking how everything was, I said it was alright I guess. She paused for a second then smiled and kept on making her rounds. We will not eat here again.
• SY

  Sophia Young

  May 11, 2026
  5.0
  Janel and Michelle were amazing! It was my first time visiting the restaurant... they gave me great recommendations on the food. Food was delicious! The Vegetable Omelet was very Beautiful and Flavorful... it was Definitely made with Love... the food was 10 out of 10... i will Definitely be back! Beautiful People, Great Food and Great Service... Definitely Made my Mother's Day....