New York Pizza | Folsom Blvd

Reviews

• PT

  Philip Tom

  May 4, 2026
  4.0
  We stopped here for an early dinner about 430pm. Ordered a medium pepperoni and medium meat lover. They were both good, I prefer the underside a little more crisp but this was okay. The guy at the counter was nice. There is one small table to dine at, so it's not dine-in. No restroom. The shopping center itself is a dump. Walking up to the store front there was at least 30 pieces of trash littering the sidewalk and entrance. If this was better kept would increase the rating.
• LA

  Leanne Anderson

  Jan 22, 2026
  1.0
  Didn't gobdf(
• DF

  D F

  Jan 15, 2026
  5.0
  Wemt to this place before under fugfynane and ownership because we were in area saw ratings took a chance even though it wasn't same owner great service prices good compared to 40 for a xl one toping,for being named straw hat it might better known as gold crown with the prices ,pizza sauce was great unique crust was good not to think butterfly flavor on crust sausage was Good pepperoni was good not to spicy ,they did say they have a place in Elk Grove so might try that one next time since it's closer but good pizza night
• ES

  Eric S

  Nov 23, 2025
  2.0
  As others have said this is not New York style pizza. It's not Little Caesars bad but maybe CiCi's Pizza or hometown buffet pizza or similar quality pizza you would find at a buffet. For me roundtable / mountain mikes is a higher quality pizza where to me this sits on the same level as dominos unfortunately. Didn't want to not like it, but it was not very good. Luckily the price seemed like a good deal but sadly the dough and overall experience left me feeling unsatisfied. Sadly I will not be coming back. The strip mall it's located in while not unsafe does feel unpleasant. Let's not even get into the long wait time although the worker seemed fine in terms of customer service. The xl with 3 toppings is enough for 2 meals for 19.99 They do have a 1 topping large for 9.99 from 12pm- 4pm which is a good alternative to take home bake pizza / frozen
• JR

  Jessica Ramirez

  Feb 5, 2025
  5.0
  Super delicious!! Must try!!