Noah's NY Bagels

Reviews

• LT

  Lisa Thompson

  Sep 28, 2026
  5.0
  The crew making the bagels and the lady making drinks here during the week are the absolute best. The place is extremely clean at all times, great attitudes, very friendly. On the other hand I refuse to come on the weekends, I was in here on Saturday and I had nothing but a bad attitude and horrible customer service. The bagel wasn’t nearly as good as when I come throughout the week. And my drinks were utterly disgusting. Ended up going to Pete’s instead. I’m never treated this way during any of my visits though the week days. I’m only giving great stars for the staff that works the mornings on the weekdays. Keep up the stellar work, you guys deserve all the recognition.
• BA

  Bilal Abboushi

  Sep 5, 2026
  5.0
  Riley absolutely made my visit. Super kind, down to earth, and genuinely one of those people who makes the whole experience better. He took great care of me and really went above and beyond. I got the Texas Brisket, the Big City Pastrami Egg, and a couple of cold brews, and everything was excellent. I also have to give a huge shoutout to Ashley because she made the drinks absolutely amazing. I needed a small adjustment to the sweetness level, and she remade the drink without any hesitation and got it perfect. That kind of patience and attention to detail really stands out. Between Riley’s awesome customer service and Ashley absolutely nailing the drinks, this was just an all-around great experience. The staff here is amazing from top to bottom — friendly, helpful, accommodating, and genuinely pleasant to deal with. Riley and Ashley both deserve some serious recognition because this is exactly the kind of service that keeps people coming back. Definitely a 5-star experience. 🔥👏
• AL

  Amanda Laus

  Aug 28, 2026
  1.0
  This morning I ordered 4 farm house bagels and a single everything bagel with onion chive shmear via Door Dash. I understand being behind on orders due to everyone ordering breakfast so the wait I didn’t mind. But I do mind that I got 5 different types of bagels (not even an everything bagel) with only shmear on it. I spent nearly $80 on this order and I got an incorrect order that would’ve costed so much less. The bagels were also not even toasted.
• AE

  Amazon Email

  Aug 20, 2026
  1.0
  I had a very disappointing experience at Noah’s NY Bagels. The customer service was poor, and one female employee with tattoos was especially rude and disrespectful. Her attitude toward customers and delivery drivers was very unprofessional and made the situation uncomfortable. I also felt that some customers were treated differently based on their race, which was very concerning and upsetting. I hope management takes this seriously and addresses the issue. Everyone—customers and delivery drivers—deserves to be treated with respect, fairness, and professionalism.
• AP

  Andrew Pointer

  Aug 9, 2026
  5.0
  These bagels are absolutely delicious. I ordered the hot pastrami bagel on a six cheese bagel and it was succulent. We stopped in the neighborhood to charge our car and decided to check out the bagel shop and now we are wishing we had one of these where we are from.

Frequently Asked Questions About Noah's NY Bagels