CC
Chris Davis CPA
5 days ago
Antonia’s pizza is the best pizza I’ve had in Paso Robles- it rivals the best in San Francisco. The crust was amazing - there are modifications one can make like garlic Parmesan for the crust alone. My husband never eats the crust edges, but he ate every bite of Antonia's pizza. The sauce and toppings were delicious with perfect ratios. Service was wonderful on Sunday afternoon 9/6/2026. This is our new go-to pizza place💕 And so conveniently located. We liked Marv's pizza and how great for us that the successor pizza maker is even better!!
AC
Amanda Cargill
Aug 27, 2026
EXCELLENT!! BETTER THAN THE OLD MARVS!
We were sad to see Marvs go, thinking how could anything compare to it, but THIS. WAS. PHENOMENAL. We got a simple large (was huge) pepperoni pizza with a few upgrades (special red sauce/SLO style crust) and it tasted like an old-world Italian family recipe. The seasoning and olive oil crust was so so good, soft with a little crunch, even the pepperoni tasted high quality. The staff was super nice in answering our menu questions and even added an order of cheese bread (perfectly seasoned, sweet marinara on the side) on the house which was extremely generous!
And say what you will, but I’m happy to see this place calm and cozy again after the obnoxious sports bar angle. Needless to say, we have found our new favorite pizza spot and can’t wait to go back to try so many things! Wish I’d taken pics of the actual food but we were so excited to try it we just dug in and it didn’t last long! Thank you for exceeding our expectations!
EG
Elizabeth Gillingham
Aug 21, 2026
We were super bummed with the food last night. We ordered two pizzas and a sandwich - with a coupon, it was $100. But support local, right?
One pizza in this photo is deep dish. I can't tell which one; the crust was the same on both. The pizza on the left was also burnt, and the toppings on both was skimpy.
I should have taken a pic of the meatball sub. It was meager. It came on a small roll, barely any sauce, no side. It was similar to a Subway meatball sandwich, but smaller. This was most definitely not a $20 sandwich.
The AI pics of food being served has got to stop. The actual food served looked nothing like this, didn't come with fries, and was a big disappointment.
HS
Hira Sheikh
Aug 19, 2026
Delicious pizza. Halal bacon and pepperoni. No bar and lots of tvs, some with kids shows on it so super family friendly. And of course open late . Great seating inside and well lit. Service was wonderful, consistently gave us free waters/sodas. And perfect location.
IV
Isaias Vasquez
Aug 14, 2026
Been here 4 times already since the reopening under new management. Every time I have gone, pizza has been absolutely perfect. Perfect in quality and presentation. You can feel the difference compared to other pizza places in their dough and the toppings. Only feedback I have is the consistency on to-go orders. Sometimes I’ll get peppers and cheeses, sometimes I don’t. Sometimes I get the cheesecake I ordered, sometimes I have to remind them about it. I assume it’s something that will get ironed out with time but still something to note. Also I’m sure a lot of time, love, and care is spent making the baklava, but I added 6 tiny pieces to my order and it was $22, which was more than my pizza. Everything else is worth the money in my opinion. Overall, once they work out the minor details, this will be my go to place to get pizza downtown! Very excited for the future!