Enjoy New York slices in the California sun. Surf Rider Pizza Co. serves east coast-style pies with classic wide-cut slices, a thin and crispy crust and fresh toppings. Surf Rider pies are baked fresh daily with our hand-tossed dough along with our delicious calzones, sandwiches, salads and more.
Explore offerings from Surf Rider Pizza on 8381 La Mesa Blvd in La Mesa, with popular ny hand tossed meat pies, ny hand tossed veggie pies, create your own, and calzones available at this location.
Menu
43 items
NY HAND TOSSED MEAT PIES
One size = 18". All pizzas made with whole milk mozzarella shredded in house daily. Dough made fresh daily from the finest ingredients.
Pepperoni Overload
$27.95
red sauce, overloaded with 3 types of pepperoni
Mt Helix
$27.95
red sauce, pepperoni, sausage & ham
L.M. Deluxe
$27.95
red sauce, pepperoni, sausage, onions, green peppers & mushrooms
pesto sauce, spinach, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers & ricotta
Basil Pesto & Ricotta
$25.95
red sauce, ricotta & basil pesto sauce
Spicy Veggie
$26.95
white sauce, banana peppers, jalapenos, artichoke hearts, onions, roma tomatoes, cilantro & "dirty" sauce
CREATE YOUR OWN
18” Fresh Cheese Pie
$21.95
housemade red sauce & mozzarella
12” Cali Cauliflower Crust
$18.95
Gluten Free Crust. housemade red sauce or alfredo sauce & mozzarella
12" Grandma's Pie
$23.95
12" rectangle pie with red sauce, mozzarella, parmesan & garlic butter
Calzone
$11.50
mozzarella & ricotta cheeses, side of housemade red sauce
Regular Toppings
$2.50
mushrooms • black olives • roma tomatoes • green peppers • jalapenos • pineapple • banana peppers • roasted red peppers • onions • fresh basil • fresh cilantro • fresh spinach • fresh arugula
Premium Toppings
$3.50
pepperoni • italian sausage • ham • housemade meatballs • roasted chicken breast • bacon • roasted garlic cloves • artichoke hearts • sundried tomatoes • feta • goat cheese • ricotta • gorgonzola • cheddar • extra mozzarella • onion jam • mike's hot honey
CALZONES
Like pizza, but different. Unique ingredients wrapped inside pizza dough and baked fresh right in the oven. Comes with red sauce on the side for your dipping pleasure.
romaine, parmesan, croutons, roasted garlic, basil & caesar dressing
Chopped Wedge
$4.95 - $13.95
romaine, bacon, tomatoes, red onion, gorgonzola, croutons & blue cheese dressing
Greek
$4.95 - $13.95
romaine, feta, black olives, tomatoes, green peppers, roasted red peppers & greek dressing
Baby Spinach
$4.95 - $13.95
spinach & arugula mix, red onion, green apple, dried cherries, candied walnuts, goat cheese & honey balsamic vinaigrette
SIDES
Side O' Fries
$5.95
Crispy fresh french fries
Garlic Knots
$4.50 - $7.95
served with red sauce
Cheese Bread
$7.50
white sauce, mozzarella & cheddar
Pesto Bread
$7.50
pesto sauce, mozzarella & ricotta
Housemade Meatballs (5)
$7.95
in red sauce
Mac & Cheese
$6.95
pasta & cheddar cheese sauce
Mozzarella Sticks
$9.95
served with red sauce
Swell Bakery
8 items
SWELL COOKIES
These MASSIVE cookies are big enough to share, but you won't want to!
Chocolate Chip
$5.00
It's a classic, get that big cup of milk ready for dunking.
Double Chocolate Chip
$5.00
If you love chocolate then imagine what happens when you double it. We engineered every way we could think of to put more chocolate inside one cookie.
S'mores Mountain
$5.00
Want to take a camping trip without leaving the dinner table? We got ya!
Blonde Rocky Road
$5.00
All the wonderful flavors of Rocky Road in a cookie. One of our most popular cookies.
Reese's Crunch
$5.00
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups baked in with a handful of peanuts and love.
Sugar Cookie with Swag
$5.00
Our Sugar Cookie topped with icing and mini M&Ms
Surfers Breakfast
$5.00
Oatmeal cookie with chocolate chips, pecans and cherries for an energized snack on your way to hit the waves.
Snickerdoodle
$5.00
Grandma's favorite! Our Sugar Cookie dusted with cinnamon sugar
Reviews
4.4
916 reviews
5 stars
593
4 stars
185
3 stars
70
2 stars
36
1 star
32
MS
Mo Stidum
6 days ago
5.0
Certified pizza is the spot for pizza in La Mesa. Best food best service. Shout out to Ally! She’s always so friendly and deserves a raise to be honest
JD
Joshua D
Jun 26, 2026
5.0
Always great customer service when ordering slices and beer at the counter. I also like they turn the sound on for Padres games and other sporting events on TV. BBQ chicken slice is my go to. Solid beer choices on tap. Cheers! 🤌🏼
DC
Dawn Coddington
Jun 14, 2026
5.0
This place has great food for picking up or eating in. Its a bit pricey but worth it. If you love whole fresh cooked garlic gloves get the suf rider pizza. This place is located right in the heart of the farmers market and car show, when its the season. Its a casual fun location. I have eaten there about 5 times and always been super happy.
AA
A
Jun 6, 2026
1.0
The staff never seemed attentive, and it often took a long time to get assistance. Even after clearly explaining the reason for my call, I was repeatedly questioned about why I was contacting them, which made the process frustrating and inefficient. On top of that, their prices are quite high compared to other options, and the lack of convenient parking only adds to the inconvenience. Overall, I did not feel the service justified the cost.
AT
Arlene Tamayo
Jun 6, 2026
5.0
Cute little pizza spot in the middle of La Mesa! The pizza was good and the service was all right, they take your order you pick up your own pizza and you don't see them again... Lol
And there was a little bit of every kind of personality in the pizza place! I will definitely be back.
Surf Rider Pizza serves east coast-style pies with classic wide-cut slices, thin and crispy crust, and fresh toppings.
What are the operating hours of Surf Rider Pizza?
Surf Rider Pizza is open daily from 11:30 AM to 9:00 PM.
Where is Surf Rider Pizza located?
Surf Rider Pizza is located at 8381 La Mesa Blvd, La Mesa, CA 91942, USA.
Can I view the menu online for Surf Rider Pizza?
Yes, you can view the menu online at https://www.surfrider-pizza.com/menu-pizza/.
Is there an option to order pizza online from Surf Rider Pizza?
Yes, you can order online at https://order.toasttab.com/online/surfrider.pizza.
What languages are supported at Surf Rider Pizza?
Surf Rider Pizza supports English language services.
What is the contact phone number for Surf Rider Pizza?
You can contact Surf Rider Pizza at +1 619-340-1270.
Are there any antique stores near Surf Rider Pizza?
Yes, nearby antique stores include Park Estate Company Antiques & Estate Sales, Favorite Things, Antiques @ The Village, and Coin Haus.
What dining options are available near Surf Rider Pizza?
Nearby dining options include Johnny B's Burgers Brew and Spirits, Gingham, Casa Gabriela, Gio Bistro and Wine Bar, Centifonti's Bar & Restaurant, BO-beau kitchen + garden, Sheldon’s Service Station, Curbside Eatery & Drinkery, Aubrey Rose Tea Room, and Coin Haus.
What nearby spots can I visit for relaxation and wellness before or after dining at Surf Rider Pizza?
You can visit Healing Therapies for physical therapy and health food, Salon Radiance and VEYRA Beauty for hair services, Beleza Waxing & Skincare Lounge for waxing and skincare treatments.
Brand Certified Facts from Surf Rider Pizza
This information is certified by Surf Rider Pizza and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified July 05, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: