Mustard Seed Gardens

Reviews

• MP

  Meghan Premuda

  Aug 25, 2026
  5.0
  Posting as a wedding professional--Mustard Seed Gardens is such a gem. It has perfect getting ready spaces for everyone, perfectly manicured spaces that create perfect spots for photos everywhere you look and the staff is wonderful. The space itself can be such a blank canvas to truly tailor to your style and specific vibe. 10/10!
• MG

  Makenzie Gillam

  Aug 17, 2026
  5.0
  Getting married at Mustard Seed Gardens was nothing short of absolutely amazing. The entire space has such natural beauty that speaks for itself. When we toured, we instantly fell in love and knew that day that is where we wanted our wedding day to be! We loved that there were spaces for the whole wedding party to get ready on wedding day. Both spaces had plenty of room and are gorgeous! Our ceremony was under the maple tree, and our reception was in the barn. Since it was a hot July day, the climate controlled barn came in handy for the reception! Aside from the appearance and beauty of the venue, the team is absolutely wonderful. They truly make the day stress-free, seamless, and such a positive experience. Bethany was incredible to work with. Emails (and there were lots of them) were responded to in such a timely and efficient manner. She was always ready to answer our next question. The team is behind the scenes but they are one of the main reasons getting married at Mustard Seed Gardens is such a wonderful experience! Truly couldn’t have asked for a better team to work with! 🫶🏼
• AA

  Allison

  Jun 8, 2026
  5.0
  We had our wedding at Mustard Seed last week and it was PERFECT! Special shout out to Bethany, Emma, Aubrey, and the whole staff. They were AMAZING and went out of their way to make sure we had a smooth day with no hiccups. Also, the bar services were amazing. Seriously, the whole team went ABOVE and beyond for us. We are forever thankful for you guys!!! THANK YOU ❤️❤️❤️
• CB

  Celie & AJ Bruns

  May 7, 2026
  5.0
  We truly fell in love with Mustard Seed Gardens the moment we saw it. It was not originally on our venue list, but after touring it, it very quickly became the one. The property is absolutely stunning — a historic barn dating back to the War of 1812 that has been beautifully brought into the 21st century while still preserving all of its incredible 1800s charm and character. The newer outdoor space, The Gable, adds such an elegant touch to the already historic venue and perfectly balances timeless and modern. A huge reason we felt so confident choosing Mustard Seed Gardens was because of **Emma**. Every meeting with her left me feeling more comfortable, reassured, and excited that we had chosen the right venue. Her calmness, professionalism, and attention to detail made such a difference throughout the planning process and on the wedding day itself. The staff overall were wonderful. The bartenders were fantastic, and the closing staff — especially Alex — were incredibly helpful and kind at the end of a long day. Security being provided by Noblesville’s finest (NPD) was excellent. Sargent Dave brought his pup, Ranger, who brought much-needed cuddles after such a big day. Our only critique was that they currently only use Zelle for online payments, and communication regarding a payment account email change was missed, causing us to accidentally send payment to a closed account. Thankfully we were able to recover it and everything worked out in the end. Overall, Mustard Seed Gardens gave us an unforgettable wedding experience filled with history, beauty, and genuinely caring people.
• SP

  Spencer Polak

  May 6, 2026
  5.0
  We could not have asked for anything more from a wedding venue. The beauty of Mustard Seed speaks for itself - stunning in person and somehow even more impressive than photos can capture. What the photos don’t show, though, is the incredible team working behind the scenes to make everything seamless. The staff is what truly set this place apart for us. From the very first time we stepped onto the property, they were completely dedicated to bringing our vision to life. They made us feel like our wedding was the only one that mattered - something we didn’t quite feel at other venues. If you’re looking for elegance without the stress, your search is over. Choosing Mustard Seed will be one of the easiest, and best, decisions you make in your wedding planning journey. **Photography by Holly Lea