Fantastic customer service! Even though it was a bit tricky with my location, the staff made the return and exchange process so smooth and hassle-free. Very professional and polite team
SR
sam rodriguez
Sep 20, 2026
My overall experience at American Eagle was extremely disappointing. The customer service was unwelcoming and the experience left a lot to be desired. The one major exception was Courtney, she was absolutely fantastic! She was friendly, attentive, and genuinely helpful, and completely stood out from the rest of the experience. Courtney honestly made the visit so much better. American Eagle definitely needs more employees like her because this place sucks.
Had the best time shopping at American Eagle today at Southcenter thanks to Brody. I felt like I was shopping with a friend the way they helped me out! I will definitely be returning. Thank you so much Brody :)
SS
Silent Bite Society
May 15, 2026
Here’s a polished version of your review:
Kayla was amazing! We were having issues receiving the text to join the membership, but she was incredibly patient with us and made sure we got signed up successfully. We truly appreciate her outstanding customer service and kindness. Thank you so much, Kayla!
Came to pick up my order I placed online in store evening of May 14th one of the sweaters I was unsure of since they didn’t have the material it was made of listed so I asked the girl (Asian with long jewelled nails) who initially helped me retrieve the order if I could return the sweater I was unsure of, she said I’m sorry we can only exchange if you’d like to look around. I let her know I already had and I would just like to return the item, when ordering it online it never said anything along the lines of final sale or exchange only and I even pulled up the confirmation email and purchase history on the app. I asked her if I could then just get a store credit and she said no sorry. After asking to speak with anyone else. The manager on duty came over I explained the situation and he was sincerely understanding and refunded me the item I no longer wanted.