FW
Farrah Weaver
Sep 17, 2026
Came in today for Sandwich must say the staff wasn’t half dead like Call of Duty Zombies like previous Subways (Indiana) and the bread was fresh definitely fresh not like A Pizza Hut box from the Super Bowl.Short lady nice ring on her finger your doing good job w this store Tuna Joint was a hit,not like the one in Indiana that one taste like Gas Station Pump (don’t ask)definitely good experience there diverse to.Lady came in obviously High off something strong smelled ruff belly button behind ear ruff she ordered her food nobody turned their nose up at her she ordered and left.That show the quality of people in there mainly the staff.CLOCK IT ⏰
Been going to different branches for years and didn’t see such an attitude from the workers, treating some people like they are begging for free food!
KW
Kaitlin “Kurtlinthegreat” Williams
Sep 4, 2026
Jacob on the night shift 9/4/26 provided the best subway customer service experience I've had in a very long time
Keep it real it’s the Staff Food and they help u like not just sub of the day.Had an Italian sandwich she made like but stuff I never thought would be good or even think about crazy ingredients are right in front of you just yeah intended to give my Son the other half but I ate the Bit frfr he’s grown but yup with them Sun Chips it’s a vinegar Mayo or the sauce that taste sweet alil bit shit good as hell yall.Its overnite eating im a Late Owl but i be full like half a day yall its the sauces you have to try.Stop eating granny’s sandwich and step out.Amanda recommended my last sandwich good looking Cuz babeeeee shit was good
WL
William Lonergan
Aug 17, 2026
From Illinois to here in New Buffalo This Subway got a Hype to it buddies go to Casino and they always stop in before leaving to go back to Illinois. Checked it out and was impressed because it’s not that it’s a Subway but a Clean Subway and the bread here doesn’t taste like others like a old deck of playing cards it’s fresh here like after eating here I’m like Damn I can eat the other half I’ll find something else for work Tomorrow.This Subway I had to leave a review Chicago Subway Indiana Subway I’ll pass but New Buffalos yea park here immediately,Footlong Cheesesteak And they put me up Chipotle sauce or Teriyaki Sauce.Good place 🫡 ✊🏾 💯 🤤