SC
Steph Christner
Apr 18, 2026
If you go into the store you’ll wait in line forever. They put every online order before the people in the store. There were 5 people in front of me when I walked in the store and 0 online tickets on the counter when I walked in. I left after 40 minutes without a sub because they did online orders and made those of us in the store wait. They even split up a mother and son to do an online order. I decided to leave when I was finally first in line and told it would still be quite a while because they had to fill these orders and there were now 4-5 tickets sitting on the counter. There were enough workers that they could’ve had one person do online orders and one make the people in the store sandwich’s, but the manager didn’t want to do that.
DS
DrRod Stodghill
Mar 21, 2026
Always a great experience. They had a large app order right before I got there and were quick about it. Always just right. Well done
Got my sandwich untoasted and soaked in mayo. Like more mayo than toppings. The manager told me he specifically made it and it was toasted (which was a lie). Then when I asked his name he called me an unflattering word and hung up on me. When I called back his excuse was he hung up to talk to his boss. Zero professionalism. Do not come here if you want your sandwich made the way you want it. You're more likely to leave with something inedible and being called out of your name by the pretend manager.
Made a serious mistake and went back a month later to try again, because I truly love subways bread. The temperature of my meatballs on my meatball sub felt like they had been in the fridge for an hour. You won't get anything good here with the current ownership, management or staff.
MB
Matthew Boese
Feb 25, 2026
I actually don’t usually give good reviews it everything was great the vegetables were great service was great. Worth every penny.
JW
Justin Wilkerson
Jan 26, 2026
Ordered a footlong meatball with double meat and cheese and got more sauce then meatballs and cheese called and the guy on the phone was rude and said not my issue ordered on the app and in the notes section I told them go light on the sauce and basically they did the opposite I counted how many meatballs there where only got 8 on a footlong which is normal but I asked for double meat so that means I should have gotten 16 won't be ordering from oskaloosa subway anytime in the near future I'll just drive to pella