Troy Baker: Allstate Insurance

Reseñas

• TD

  tyler dean

  Apr 28, 2026
  5.0
  Great Insurance Agency. Joe Sparacio has done an incredible job handling all of my insurance needs. He is incredibly proactive on my behalf, and is a 10/10 to work with. I would highly recommend Baker Insurance agency and ask for Joe.
• GR

  Gerry Rosenblum

  Sep 30, 2025
  1.0
  I had auto insurance with Allstate for more than 30 years. When I finally got off my butt and got a quote from Geico it was $1,000's of dollars less per year for the same exact insurance. When I called to cancel my policy I was told that they would have to cancel my Umbrella policy as well, since you had to have Auto to have an Umbrella. Months later I get a bill for the Umbrella policy as they did not cancel it when I cancelled my Auto policy. Interesting that they lied when they said you couldn't have the Umbrella without the Auto. I won't pay it and they sent it to a collection company. When I called, Troy has an attitude and tells me there is nothing he can do, that I should call Allstate directly and ask for the recorded call to see what happened. I will be certain to spread the word around Marco Island as to how poorly this was handled.
• BP

  Beach Please

  Jun 10, 2024
  1.0
  Yeny just wasted 2 weeks of my time with taking DAYS to respond to emails/texts/etc. I would think twice before using them for a quote, especially if you are in a tight time crunch! She was also very confrontational and tried to place blame on me for her shortcomings. I will definitely make sure that I let everyone I know in SW FL to NOT use Tony Baker's office!
• CS

  CJ S

  Jan 2, 2022
  5.0
  Best option Marco Island