Tiffany & Co.

Reviews

• GC

  Gjovana Camaj

  Apr 13, 2026
  1.0
  Not a Good experience the staff (women’s) they wanna sell you so bad and they have such a crazy bad attitude !! Never going back again!!!
• KK

  Kristina

  Dec 5, 2025
  5.0
  This is my third time purchasing from Tiffany & Co., and specifically from this location. I’ve always been incredibly impressed with the quality of their jewelry. As I mentioned to Michael, the ring I already own is about five years old, and I’ve never once brought it in for a cleaning. I’ve even worn it while cleaning the house and using bleach, and it still looks brand new. Tiffany isn’t just timeless—it’s practically indestructible. “Impressed” doesn’t even begin to describe the quality, which is exactly why I continue to come back. I’ve always had pleasant experiences at this store, but I was exceptionally pleased with the customer service I received from Michael today. I was genuinely surprised to learn he is fairly new, because he was incredibly knowledgeable, patient, and attentive. I came in with a specific ring in mind, but once I tried it on, I didn’t love how it looked in person. Michael then asked if I’d like to try the smaller version—something I didn’t even know existed. I tried it on and liked it, but wasn’t completely sure. Then he showed it to me in rose gold, which looked more like yellow gold to me, but it complemented my skin tone so beautifully that I instantly loved it. I also wanted to look around the store in case I missed something online, and Michael was extremely patient. He walked the entire store with me, showing me different pieces, taking them out of the cases, and making sure I felt comfortable with each size and style. In the end, I chose the smaller Love Ring. While he boxed everything up, he even took the time to share the story of the designer, which made the experience feel even more special. Not only am I impressed with Tiffany, but I am also very impressed with Michael. I truly hope he receives the recognition he deserves and continues to grow within Tiffany. This ring is a Christmas gift from my parents, and it means a great deal to me. Thank you so much, Michael! As always, I look forward to returning to Tiffany in Paramus.
• MM

  Michael McGuirk

  Dec 25, 2022
  5.0
  Very helpful staff. Got us exactly what we were looking for and more.
• AN

  Akbar Nahad

  Sep 8, 2020
  1.0
  Visited Garden State Plaza location in NJ. Very disappointed as they offered no help in cleaning my wife’s engagement ring that was purchased here in 2014 and also not offered appraisal service. Some insurance companies require current valuation to keep the article insured at current value. There were about 8 stuff working in the store, all in black suit and tie and they just sit there and look pretty. When we purchased the ring, we were promised lifetime cleaning service and that was one of the factors I decided for Tiffany relative to other options, but today I was let down by their unhelpful staff and lack of professionalism. I am sharing this here because I don’t want others to have a negative experience despite paying almost twice for what you get. I knew they but I paid the money because of the service which they failed to deliver today. Do your research and pause before you make a purchase from this jeweler. Don’t just buy the ring because the name says Tiffany and there is a certificate number. It means nothing.
• CV

  Chris V

  Apr 4, 2019
  5.0
  Very respectful staff, extremely friendly, not pushy, no multiple followup calls like the endless ones you get from car dealers. The staff was all awesome but John C and Daniel were truly amazing. Both went above and beyond and continue to do so every time I or my fiance walk in. Price is high but its Tiffanys and you get what you pay for. Highly recommend this store and those two gentleman!