Best Western Plus Brooklyn Bay Hotel

Reviews

• SC

  Stephanie Church

  1 day ago
  4.0
  Rooms were exceptionally clean
• MH

  Marla Hockfeld

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Modern, clean, hotel located where we needed to be. MUCH pricier than I expected with LOUD & CONSTANT street noise. If noise sensitive, you're going to need your ear plugs or noise cancelling headphones to allow for a good night's sleep. There's a bodega 1 block from the hotel that has fantastic bagels, deli salads & sandwiches, toiletries & beverages, all reasonably priced. Also, there's a bus stop at the front entrance should you need public transportation.
• MI

  MD Liton Islam

  May 12, 2026
  5.0
  I had a wonderful experience at the Best Western Plus Brooklyn Bay Hotel. The rooms were spacious, spotless, and offered a beautiful view of the bay. The staff was professional and went out of their way to ensure a comfortable stay. The complimentary breakfast was a great bonus. Definitely my go-to place in Brooklyn from now on!
• KT

  Kaheem Thomas

  Apr 19, 2026
  5.0
  The staff was friendly and helpful. They all seemed happy. Amazing room. The parking was kind of tight, but great full for the free parking.
• ML

  Marianna Leah

  Apr 11, 2026
  5.0
  Great place to stay. Stayed here with family during a winter storm while being misplaced due to a frozen pipe issue and had no running water at the house. The hotel staff was very kind, courteous, and extremely accommodating. If you need a place to stay overnight or for longer and you are in the sheepshead Bay area then this is definitely the spot for you. It's convenient location is close to a lot of different food venues, transportation, including a bus stop on the same block, and the gorgeous marina across. The area is great!