Best Western Carlisle

Reviews

• SM

  Sativa Mae

  1 day ago
  1.0
  Quin was rude! I won’t bother staying here again when I come to town. Not after that and then coming on here and reading the reviews
• BB

  Brea Arvidson (Brea)

  Dec 20, 2025
  3.0
  Pet friendly, so that's nice. Front desk was accommodating and welcoming. They left us homemade Holiday cookies in the room, so that was thoughtful. The room? Wuf. Roaches, for one. I saw one scoot out to the cookie bag. The room was cold when we got there and figured out the heat was on or off, with no in between. The room smelled musty/damp even though it's winter and the heater should be drying it out. Beds were older, and visibly deeply sagging. Even at a quick glance, the bathroom could have been cleaner - dirt and dust left in the corners on the floor. The toilet seat was loose. I went to pull my phone charger out of the desk outlet and the entire thing came out of the wall. Seems like the reviews for this place are all over the place, so maybe some rooms are fine.
• JS

  Jeff Stallone

  Oct 28, 2025
  5.0
  There was a small problem this morning and management took it and fixed. I still give it all the 5 stars. Because there are great people. The rooms are clean and the breakfast is just. Continental, but a good one.
• TW

  TeKiesha Wiggins

  Oct 16, 2025
  5.0
  Both ladies at the front desk were welcoming very sweet and helpful. The gentleman working the breakfast area was friendly and had a beautiful smile for all! The room was clean, bed was comfortable. Breakfast was good, fully stocked and the area was clean. Location was easy access from the highway. We stayed here as a starting point to visit Gettysburg and it worked out great! We will be staying here anytime we travel through the area.
• GB

  Grace Blessing

  Oct 12, 2025
  1.0
  My experience was horrid. It was awful from the beginning so that's where I'll start. When we walked in, only 2 carts were available for our bags. One of them only had half of it's wheels. When we were walking back to the front of the building, we noticed that there is not a wheelchair ramp. So, not up to code. All of my belongings spilled into the street when I was attempting to lift the cart by myself onto the sidewalk. Of course, no help was offered. When we finally got to the front desk, we were visibly frustrated and the receptionist was attempting to deny us service by pretending she didn't speak English. When we told her we had spoken to her prior with no issue, she proceeded to check us in. I haven't even gotten to the best part. It's midnight when we're checking in. My best friends wedding is the next day. We're coming in, wedding dress in hand. At this point, another employee came out of the back room. Right off the bat- AWFUL attitude. I never got her name but she had an awful wig. We had confirmed ahead of time that we could have a later check out for us to get ready in the morning. They were again, arguing and trying to deny us the late check out. We finally got our room key. We walked back to our room, got the cart inside, turned around to shut the door, and realized the door wouldn't shut because the hinge/lock was broken. We then asked to be moved to a different room. The woman with the awful wig came out (attitude of course). She told us that it was just an issue with the screws and brushed it off as if we were just being dramatic and that she could fix it herself. At this point, we were visibly upset and wanting a different room because we didn't feel comfortable. She started yelling and slamming drawers. Saying she was tired, had a long day from playing phone tag, and just needed to leave. She was also complaining about my friend (the bride literally holding her wedding dress) and yelling about how she was dramatic for requesting a new room and saying she couldn't accommodate her. We were eventually moved to a different room. First thing we see is a roach on the floor. Yes, a roach. We go in, set our things down and I head for the shower. The tub was disgusting. The room looks like it's a motel 6 with the landlord special. There was some odd colored staining on the chairs as well. All in all, bad experience but the wedding was an absolute banger for anyone wondering :)

Frequently Asked Questions About Best Western Carlisle