The Fifth Avenue Hotel

Reviews

• AK

  Amir Koopaei

  1 day ago
  5.0
  Some hotels are beautiful. Some have great service. It’s rare to find one that does both at this level. Our stay at The Fifth Avenue Hotel was one of the best hotel experiences we’ve ever had. From the moment we arrived, Michelle at the front desk set the tone: warm, sharp, and genuinely welcoming. Karys went above and beyond in curating our stay and making everything feel seamless. Katie in guest services was equally impressive, always responsive and thoughtful. Huge thanks as well to Todd, the hotel manager. It’s clear he is leading something very special here. The butler service was another standout. Refined, attentive, and genuinely helpful without ever feeling intrusive. The included minibar was also such a thoughtful touch. It made the room feel generous and genuinely guest-focused. The hotel itself is unforgettable. In a world where so many luxury hotels have gone minimal, neutral, and almost interchangeable, The Fifth Avenue Hotel embraces maximalism with real class. The design is layered, rich, bold, and full of character, but never tacky or overdone. Every space feels intentional. Portrait Bar deserves its own mention. It has exactly the kind of atmosphere you hope to find in New York: elegant, intimate, beautifully designed, and full of character. And the scent is incredible. Fresh, green, and refined. You notice it the moment you walk in, and somehow it becomes part of the memory of the stay. The service here isn’t just polished. It’s intuitive. We felt genuinely taken care of the entire time. This will absolutely be our hotel whenever we’re in New York, and we’ll be recommending it to everyone we know.
• SS

  SJ

  6 days ago
  5.0
  Everything about this hotel is superb! Rooms, service, staff, food & bev! Can’t wait to come back!!!!
• AA

  Abdo Ahmed

  6 days ago
  5.0
  Dear friend, I hope you are well. I write to you with respect and sincerity, not to argue, but to share something precious with you. I invite you to look into Islam with an open heart and open mind. Islam teaches pure devotion to God alone — the One Creator of the heavens and the earth, who has no partner, no equal, and no need for anything. He is perfect, eternal, all-powerful, and full of mercy. This simple and clear belief is deeply rooted in reason and revelation. Muslims also love and honor Jesus (peace be upon him). We believe he was one of the greatest prophets, born miraculously to the Virgin Mary, and sent with guidance and miracles by God's permission. But we do not worship him. We believe worship belongs to God alone. There are sincere questions that many people ask about Christianity: 1. If God is One, how can He be three persons at the same time? The doctrine of the Trinity is difficult to reconcile with the clear message of pure monotheism taught by the prophets. 2. If Jesus prayed to God, depended on God, and said he could do nothing by himself, does this not show that he was a servant and messenger of God rather than God Himself? 3. If God is perfect and immortal, how can He die? Islam teaches that God is above weakness, suffering, and death. 4. The Bible has many versions, translations, and textual differences acknowledged by scholars. In contrast, the Qur’an has been preserved and memorized generation after generation in its original language. The Qur’an calls people back to the faith of Abraham, Moses, Jesus, and all prophets: worship God alone, obey Him, repent to Him, and live righteously. Islam offers a direct relationship with God — no intermediaries, no inherited sin, and no confusion. Every soul is responsible for its own deeds, and God's mercy is always near to those who turn to Him sincerely. I kindly invite you to read the Qur’an, especially with reflection and sincerity. Ask the Creator to guide you to the truth, wherever it may be. A sincere prayer from the heart is never lost. May God guide us all to what is true and pleasing to Him. With respect and kindness.
• GH

  Glenn Hebert

  Apr 23, 2026
  5.0
  While the location and facilities are top notch, it is the staff that really makes this hotel stand out. Of the dozen or so staff members that i interacted with, each one contributed (sometimes in unique and unexpected ways) to a wonderful stay. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
• KL

  Kendall Lockard

  Apr 12, 2026
  5.0
  Had such an amazing experience here, I’ve stayed at quite a few 5-stars in NYC and the service here was amazing. Everyone who works here is so sweet and goes out of their way to make you feel welcome. Definitely my go-to hotel now

Frequently Asked Questions About The Fifth Avenue Hotel