Business Details
About
Coin Dealer
Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay is the go to place to buy and sell your jewelry, coins, memorabilia and more in the greater Oyster Bay, NY area.
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.1
61 reviews
5 stars
45
4 stars
2
3 stars0
2 stars
2
1 star
12
- EBelaine bermasDec 12, 20255.0My family and I have used Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay for at least ten years. Recently, with the price of silver having increased tremendously, I decided to sell all my sterling silver pieces which included dinnerware, jewelry, and a large coin collection. Ira and Chelsea gave us their full attention and we found them knowledgeable, thorough, and careful in their attempt to accurately assess the value of everything we brought to them and to give us a fair price. We were thrilled with the service we received and the integrity that they showed while patiently answering any/all of our questions. We have returned there three times with our own possessions and have returned with other family members and friends who wished to sell their own silver. We cannot recommend Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay highly enough. We left each time feeling assured that we had been treated well.
- FCFeelsk CNov 29, 20255.0I’m an aspiring jeweler, caster, and metal smith, Chelsea was the friendliest and most intelligent and just nice to interact with. She answered all my questions and attentively searched for the best deal I could get, I sold my American eagle for top dollar, and was able to trade for a beautiful ruby and a 12 gram bracelet as well as a 95% 85 gram sterling bar, I have inspiration, more knowledge and a potentially interested business partner for the future, I could not be any more exited to use the materials I traded and will definitely be going back for more in the future and showing Chelsea and the rest of the staff what I was able to create with her providence
- MZMichelle Zeitlin-FirouztaleNov 13, 20255.0It was a pleasure working with Chelsea! She was friendly, professional, and extremely knowledgeable. She took her time looking over each of my jewelry pieces and gave me a fair offer that left me walking out with a big smile. I’d definitely recommend Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay to anyone wanting to sell jewelry, gold, or coins.
- SMSheryl M.Nov 12, 20255.0Top quality jewelry and service! Highly recommend! Bought multiple pieces from them and love each and every one! Chelsea is so easy to work with and knows her stuff!
- AHAmanda HeinrichSep 9, 20251.0I would like to give this guy owner specifically a no star review. I would have preferred a lesson on how my money was a replica instead of an attitude as if I was trying to get one over on the business. So now that Google has explained how my money wasn’t real………. Was it a British knock off from the 1800s? Or a replica from somewhere between the 60s or 70s? Your rudeness was completely unacceptable. Flat out. If you’re having a bad day go ahead and stay home. I guess the only way you got this one star is the respectful woman in the blue cast. I hope she heals well and has a great day.
Frequently Asked Questions About Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay
Where are your locations?
Coin galleries of Oyster Bay operates three locations across Long Island. Our Oyster Bay branch is situated at 90 South Street, Oyster Bay, NY 11771. In Lynbrook, you can find us at 629 Sunrise Highway, Lynbrook, NY 11563. Our Levittown location is at 3535 Hempstead Turnpike, Levittown, NY 11756.
What items do you buy?
Our purchasing inventory includes a wide range of items such as gold and silver jewelry, coins, bullion, paper money, sports memorabilia, sterling silverware, platinum, and various other collectibles.
Do you offer cash for gold?
Yes, we provide competitive cash payments for gold and other precious metals. We also offer special promotions, including bonus payments for large transactions. For example, customers selling $10,000 worth of gold jewelry may receive an additional $500 bonus.
Where are the Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay locations?
Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay has three locations across Long Island: 90 South Street, Oyster Bay, NY 11771; 629 Sunrise Highway, Lynbrook, NY 11563; and 3535 Hempstead Turnpike, Levittown, NY 11756.
What types of items does Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay buy?
They buy gold and silver jewelry, coins, bullion, paper money, sports memorabilia, sterling silverware, platinum, and various other collectibles.
Does Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay offer cash for gold?
Yes, they provide competitive cash payments for gold and other precious metals, including special promotions such as bonus payments on large transactions.
What are the operating hours of Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay?
They are open Monday through Friday from 10:30 AM to 5:30 PM and are closed on Saturdays and Sundays, as well as major holidays like Thanksgiving, Christmas, and New Year's Day.
What payment options are accepted at Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay?
Accepted payment options include American Express, Cash, Check, Discover, Mastercard, Visa, and Zelle.
What services does Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay provide?
They offer gold buying, rare coin sales, appraising coin collections, buying and selling collectible memorabilia, buying gold and silver bullion, selling jewelry and diamond engagement rings, and estate services.
Can I find dining options near Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay?
Yes, nearby dining options include Italian and bar Gioia, Japanese restaurant Nikkei of Peru, Mexican restaurant Lourdes Mexican Grill, French restaurant L'Etoile, American restaurant Harborside Delicatessen, and ice cream spots like Sabrina's Candy & Creamery and Carvel Ice Cream.
What nearby retail stores can customers visit around Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay?
Nearby retail options include The Jewelry Gallery of Oyster Bay, Nobman's Hardware, Provisions Market grocery store, and Long Island Picture Frame and Art Gallery of Oyster Bay.
Are there nearby services related to repairs or professional support near Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay?
Yes, services nearby include South Street Plumbing and Heating for HVAC and plumbing, Oyster Bay Yoga studio for fitness, a dental office Precision Oyster Bay Family Dental & Specialty, and a probate lawyer for legal services.
How can customers combine a visit to Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay with other local activities?
Customers can enjoy a meal at one of the nearby restaurants, visit local art galleries like The Madd Potter, get a haircut at Oyster Bay Barbers, or grab a sweet treat at Sabrina's Candy & Creamery before or after visiting the Coin Galleries store.