Old World Coin

Reviews

• SS

  Steve Schindler

  Mar 27, 2026
  5.0
  Fair prices, friendly and helpful staff. Nice selection. Might be my new go to store. The only downside is that while they do have 90% they don't allow you to pick through it. You tell them what you want and they bring it to you. At least that's the way it was a few years ago when I started stacking. I've been buying bullion and numismatics lately so I don't know if it is still the same or not.
• SH

  Sean Hayes

  Mar 16, 2026
  5.0
  Great store that I’ve been going to since I was a kid with my dad. The staff/owner are knowledgeable, clear, and reasonable. When it comes to selling & purchases, they give fair prices and are straightforward on what you have. Sometimes you can find great deals on the bid wall as well. A hidden gem 💎
• MM

  Marcian

  Mar 1, 2026
  5.0
  Honesty, communication and transparency are few qualities left in today's shopping. These guys are honest, fair and even with the wild volatility of today's markets they give you honest truth. They don't mark up metals like most and are extremely courteous.
• EL

  Evan larson

  Feb 12, 2026
  5.0
  Great place for all sorts of coins, metals, and collectables. Been going here for years and its always the same helpful staff.
• JC

  Jeff Conyers

  Jan 28, 2026
  2.0
  Ive given this place 10 stars for years until today. Ive been coming here to Old world coin McHenry for well over 18 years. Ive been buying and selling gold and silver here going all the way back to when I think Merv and the old crew ran things. It was a super cool one of a kind store that brought you back to the old days. Until today, I was in there turning in Gold and Silver jewerly from my belated baby sister for my mother and the new owner or manager was very cocky arrogant and rude. Right in front of me out loud he literally said to another customer while I was standing there everyone coming in to his store today was 90/10 and 90% he hates and 10% he likes. Not sure who he was referencing but I was only 1 of 2 other customers in the store at the time. I own several businesses and if I said that in front of customers or clients Id be out of business. Mind blown at his behavior. I loved this store and have literally told tons of people about Old World Coin through out the years but Im not sure I will continue to do so if he hates most people coming through his doors.