Old World Coin

4.2
162 reviews
string

About

Coin DealerCoin Collecting
Old World Coin is not just a website we are a true brick and mortar company - part of the community. With our expert staff, we continue to grow as a company that supports hobbyists as well as investors.

Location

Old World Coin
1301 Riverside Drive, McHenry, IL
60050, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.2
162 reviews
5 stars
113
4 stars
16
3 stars
6
2 stars
2
1 star
25

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Customer Service

Feedback is mixed regarding customer service; while some customers praise the friendly and helpful staff, others report rude and unprofessional behavior from certain employees.

Knowledge and Expertise

Many customers appreciate the staff's knowledge and expertise in coins and precious metals, often highlighting their willingness to educate customers.

Pricing Issues

Several reviews mention dissatisfaction with pricing, with some customers feeling they were lowballed or offered unfair prices for their items.

Selection Variety

Customers frequently commend the shop for its wide selection of coins and collectibles, making it a popular destination for both buying and selling.

Professionalism

There are contrasting opinions on professionalism; while some customers find the staff to be professional and trustworthy, others describe experiences of unprofessionalism.
  • CC
    Cole
    Nov 7, 2025
    5.0
    If you guys and girls have any extra world wide coins that you just want to get rid of, send it to me please. It’s my 13th birthday πŸ₯ΊπŸ™πŸ™
  • CC
    Cynthia Cammarata
    Oct 19, 2025
    5.0
    Went in the other day, not knowing what to expect. Everyone was so nice answering my questions and giving me a good deal. If you have any business buying or selling coins these gentlemen where whoneed to go see.
  • TB
    Tom Brinkman
    Oct 15, 2025
    5.0
    It's the best place around. Knowledgeable, great stock, and FAIR. Call that 3 letter place and ask their prices. You'll find out in a hurry where you want to conduct business. It's a great shop just to look around as well.
  • TT
    TheRealx5150xi
    Oct 13, 2025
    1.0
    This place is very unreasonable with their prices and very disrespectful to customers coming in. The guy with a beer gut that has thee worst attitude I have ever come across towards every customer needs to be fired or removed from the front. Pure waste of everyone's time he deals with, on top of ridiculous side comments to people he is not even dealing with... Guy seriously needs a vacation or some time to get himself together.
  • JY
    josh yenny
    Oct 11, 2025
    5.0
    All business, walked in and was immediately greeted and my coin taken to be valued. It was$105 more than the first place I went, and I was in and out with the cash in about 5 minutes. To be clear,, I only had one gold coin that was easily identified, but I also read the bad reviews before I went and knew what to expect. Definitely will be going back when I get sorted a little better.

Frequently Asked Questions About Old World Coin

What type of business is Old World Coin and how does it serve the community?

Old World Coin is a brick-and-mortar coin dealer and coin collecting shop with expert staff supporting hobbyists and investors in the community.

Where is Old World Coin located?

Old World Coin is located at 1301 Riverside Drive, McHenry, IL 60050, USA.