Old World Coin is not just a website we are a true brick and mortar company - part of the community. With our expert staff, we continue to grow as a company that supports hobbyists as well as investors.
Feedback on staff behavior is mixed; while some customers praise the friendly and helpful service, others report rude and unprofessional interactions.
Pricing
Many customers appreciate the competitive pricing and fair offers for buying and selling coins, although some express dissatisfaction with lowball offers.
Knowledgeability
The staff is frequently described as knowledgeable and informative, providing valuable insights to customers about coins and collectibles.
Store Environment
The shop is noted for having a good selection of coins and collectibles, but some reviews mention a need for better upkeep and a more welcoming atmosphere.
IK
Ian Kelly
5 days ago
5.0
The staff are incredibly knowledgeable, and their pricing is transparent and honest. I always look forward to visiting and plan on returning.
LG
LINDA Garofalo
Dec 31, 2025
5.0
Everyone was so very nice at this place. Highly recommend
EN
eli nelson
Dec 30, 2025
5.0
Great and fair prices when selling my silver and gold. Super helpful and friendly. Better than any other shop I talked to.
SS
Shane
Dec 27, 2025
5.0
Honest and knowledgeable staff.
EG
Entropy Gizmo
Nov 30, 2025
4.0
Was in recently to buy a 1 ozt AGE. Was pleasantly surprised their premium on it was less than 3%. That's very competitive.
Can only speak to the buying side, as I haven't sold anything there yet, but this shop might become my main go-to. Staff was pleasant and helpful, as well.
So, why four, and not five stars? That's just me. Something has to be very special to get five outta me. Give this store a try. IMHO, Old World should have a slightly higher Google score. Maybe getting suppressed by competitors?
What type of business is Old World Coin and how does it serve the community?
Old World Coin is a brick-and-mortar coin dealer and coin collecting shop with expert staff supporting hobbyists and investors in the community.
Where is Old World Coin located?
Old World Coin is located at 1301 Riverside Drive, McHenry, IL 60050, USA.
What are the store hours for Old World Coin?
Old World Coin is open Monday through Friday from 9:30 AM to 3:00 PM, Saturdays from 9:30 AM to 1:00 PM, and is closed on Sundays.
How can I contact Old World Coin?
You can contact Old World Coin by calling +1 815-344-8800 or emailing oldworldcoin@yahoo.com.
Does Old World Coin have an online presence?
Yes, Old World Coin's website is http://owcoin.com/ and they also have a Facebook page at https://www.facebook.com/109346640547540.
Are there any nearby dining options close to Old World Coin?
Nearby dining options include Foxhole Pizza and Pub, Bimbos Italian Kitchen, Windhill Pancake Parlor, Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard, and Bimbo's Ristorante.
What nearby amenities can I visit after shopping at Old World Coin?
You can visit nearby places like Riverside Bake Shop for desserts, Reeses Barkery & Pawtique for coffee and pet supplies, or relax at Salon Blu beauty and spa.
Are there any nearby financial services or ATMs near Old World Coin?
Yes, there is a LibertyX Bitcoin ATM nearby providing ATM, financial service, and currency exchange services.
Can visitors find accommodation near Old World Coin?
Yes, the Riverside Hotel is a nearby accommodation option close to Old World Coin.
What types of businesses surround Old World Coin?
Near Old World Coin are various businesses including jewelry stores like Old World Gem & Jewelry, insurance agencies such as George Thompson Insurance Agency, beauty salons, clothing stores, and dental associates.