Rummele's Jewelers Green Bay

Reviews

• LH

  Laura Haban

  Jun 18, 2026
  5.0
  I had walked into Rummel’s and the service was absolutely fantastic. I was seeking a jeweler for the last several years to fix a vintage Bulova watch that had some sentimental value. I had seriously been to five or six different jewelers in the area and none of them could replace the battery on this time piece and understand the particular mechanisms that it has. The Horologist was absolutely fantastic and I am so excited to have this unique time peace in working order again. Andy, one of the sales people was incredibly helpful and ended up cleaning my wedding ring and I don’t think it’s ever looked better. Very much recommend this company incredibly knowledgeable and a very bespoke experience.
• SF

  Scott Forbes

  Mar 5, 2026
  5.0
  I have a rather inexpensive watch that I like. I have had it for years. The battery went out. I didn't know if Rummele's could change the battery, as it's not a brand they sell and I didn't buy it there. I went in and met with Andy. He was friendly and quickly took my watch back to their watchmaker. They were able to change the battery while I waited. The cost? It was shockingly low. I had assumed since they carry luxury time pieces it would be very expensive. To my surprise, I was wrong. They charged less than I have previously paid for the exact same service elsewhere. Truly the best experience I have ever had with a jewelry store. Thank you Rummele's and Andy! You are the very best and I will be back.
• JJ

  J. Johnson

  Mar 1, 2026
  5.0
  Rummeles Jewelry and “Mr. Rolex” delivered truly best-in-class customer service. Growing up in Green Bay, I never imagined I would one day own a Rolex or be able to shop here. When the time finally came and I was ready to make that investment, there was no question where I was going — straight to David, the absolute godfather of sourcing unique and hard-to-find models. He exceeded every expectation. From the first conversation, personalized engraving to the final handshake, the experience was personal, professional, and memorable. David not only secured my Rolex Sky-Dweller masterpiece, but he also took the time to walk me through every feature with care and precision. The attention to detail and genuine excitement for his clients is unmatched. And yes — celebrating the moment with a well-earned beer afterward made it even more special. I couldn’t be more proud or grateful for the experience. If you’re considering a fine timepiece and want white-glove treatment with hometown integrity, Rummeles is the only place to go. Highly recommend.
• LW

  Leann Wettstein

  Feb 27, 2026
  5.0
  Bought a new wedding ring and Tracy helped me pick the most gorgeous ring!!! Then Alex helped us pick the perfect bands!!! The only jewelry store we will go to now. Would give 10 stars if I could. Thanks you guys!!!
• JJ

  JonathanGlassco

  Feb 26, 2026
  5.0
  Doug was great to work with when purchasing a new watch. I highly recommend him and Rummele’s!

Frequently Asked Questions About Rummele's Jewelers Green Bay