JewelRecycle, LLC

Reviews

• AS

  Amy Shaw

  4 days ago
  5.0
  If I could give JewelRecycle 6 stars, I would! Katie was the one who helped me, and she was fantastic. The process was incredibly quick—I was in and out within 5 minutes and got even more than I expected. A very professional place, and I couldn't recommend them enough!
• ES

  Emily Snell

  May 11, 2026
  5.0
  Phillip was very helpful, explained everything to me around pricing and testing. Overall very fun experience, I learned a lot and left with a good chunk of money!
• TM

  T McK

  May 7, 2026
  1.0
  Not sure how they have all these 5 star reviews. I was offered 63% of melt value for 14K gold, which is on the very low end of typical payouts. Most buyers are closer to 70–80% or higher depending on the situation. If you don’t know how to calculate melt value, this might seem fine — but if you do, it’s not competitive. I’d definitely recommend getting multiple quotes before selling here.
• RM

  Rachel Milliken

  Apr 29, 2026
  5.0
  Stopped in to sell some gold and get an idea of whether a few other items might be worth selling. Penny helped me and was incredibly kind and welcoming throughout the entire process. Even though some of my items couldn’t be accepted, she took the time to clearly explain why and answered all of my questions with patience. I had a great experience and would absolutely recommend this business to anyone looking to sell gold or jewelry. 🥰😊
• SC

  Stephanie Cruz

  Apr 26, 2026
  1.0
  Honestly, based on the reviews, I was expecting a lot more from this place. I brought in my wedding rings to see how much I could get for them. We purchased them at KAY Jewelers in 2020, and the smaller ring alone cost $2,600, and the larger one was around $6,000. We have all the paperwork stored away, but since they said they didn't need it, I didn't bring it. I assumed their evaluation process was trustworthy and would provide a fair quote. I was offered $471 for BOTH rings, which isn't even close to half of what the smaller one alone is worth. It made me question whether they judged people based on age or appearance, like assuming I didn't know the value of what I had or worse, acting like it wasn't mine. Even the security guard moved closer to me for no reason while I was simply waiting for the quote. I came home, found the paperwork, and will definitely be going somewhere else. I'm not sure what kind of process they use here, whether it's because I didn't bring the papers or something else, but if you know the value of your jewelry, I recommend going somewhere else.

Frequently Asked Questions About JewelRecycle, LLC