American Eagle Store

Reviews

• PB

  Paul Brownlee

  Feb 24, 2026
  2.0
  I bought a few items, and came back to return a shirt that didn't fit. I had the card I used but not the receipt. The manager told me firmly "we can't do any returns without the receipt". So I went home, found the receipt and came back another day. To complete the return they asked for my name and address. I said I don't want to give my address. They insisted, "in case something goes wrong with the return". I guess the physical receipt and the card used isn't enough? Thankfully I had a rewards account they could link it to and complete the return. Seems a bit over the top for a simple return, not sure I'll be doing any more shopping there.
• SL

  Sarah Lutiger

  Jan 3, 2026
  2.0
  Appreciate that we have a store in Bozeman now, but the fact that we are unable to return clothing that my daughter got for Christmas that doesn’t fit her because it was a gift and we don’t have the original email feels archaic. We just went through the same thing at Anthropologie and they had absolutely no issue with us returning an item with just the packing slip. Get with the times!!
• SM

  Sierra McAuliffe

  Aug 3, 2025
  1.0
  Went in at 12 on 7/3 for the first time and had a horrible experience. No one greeted me, I had to try on clothes, and used the button to call for help and no one came even the girl in the next stall was waiting for help and she started saying "hello is anyone gonna help me?". I gave up and went to find stuff on my own. I went to the counter to ask if I could put stuff aside that I wanted as it was alot and I wasnt done. No one helped me. I went to a blonde curly haired girl with glasses and she just looked at me like I was interrupting her chat with the other employee. There was a male also working and walked passed me multiple times not once asking if I needed help or if he could take all the clothes from me that I wanted. The only helpful person was Sierra. She at least helped me at the counter, and ordered shorts for me and made small talk. Regardless, im not sure ill be back for awhile now. Really disappointing for a new store.
• KB

  K B

  Jul 1, 2025
  1.0
  I'm 8 months pregnant and the girl would not shut up about how the shirts ran small and I needed to size up. She brought it up three times. Surprise! They fit! Didn't buy though because of that rude girl. Like God forbid I come into your store.