Plato's Closet

Reviews

• FL

  Fumi Lola

  2 days ago
  2.0
  I decided to try the Manchester location today since the buying counter at Florissant was closed. The staff here were very polite and pleasant to work with, but the buying process remains disappointing. When I asked about their selection criteria, the employee explained that they buy based on current trends and newer styles. However, looking through their actual racks, a huge portion of the inventory is clearly outdated (very much 2010s-core). It doesn't align with their claim of prioritizing modern trends over what customers bring in. I haven't brought clothes to Plato's Closet in years hoping their evaluation process had improved, but it's still the exact same. They also claimed that a lot of my clothing had wear and tear which is widely inaccurate. I dropped off my items at 1:00pm and they were finished sorting by 1:17pm. So I’m not going to assume that did a true assessment of each piece of clothing being that I had well over 100 items they didn’t throughly look through. If you are looking to clear out your closet, you're much better off donating to a shelter, going to a traditional thrift store/Goodwill, or listing items on Facebook Marketplace where you'll actually make decent money. I won't be returning.
• RM

  Rayna Maschan

  Aug 9, 2026
  3.0
  The selection is typically great, though we do struggle to find things in our specific sizes sometimes, i think that's pretty normal for a resale shop. The only complaint i think both myself and my teens have would be the music. The atmosphere is very over stimulating and we tend to avoid this specific Platos because of it. I think if the music wasn't so loud, maybe that would help have a more relaxing and enjoyable atmosphere. Especially when its a busy day. Otherwise, its a decent location.
• MU

  Melony Utzler

  Aug 5, 2026
  5.0
  Found many trendy items for young people. larger then it looks and clean store.
• BB

  Bay

  Aug 1, 2026
  5.0
  Platos is my favorite shop in all time, everything is so cheap and is truly high quality and all employees are so kind.
• BS

  bella schlegl

  Jul 28, 2026
  1.0
  the Brunette manager on June 27th 7pm embarrassed me and accused me of tag swapping when I didn’t. I ripped the tag off in the dressing room because it was right on me. She didn’t give me the 2 bucks for the dress and priced it at 8. I paid the 8. I also had a 14 dollar leggings and another clearance item. So 3 things. 2 were clearance. It should have been 18 bucks 20 with tax. I paid 36 bucks. It sounded wrong and I asked if that was the price 14 plus 8 plus 2. Should have been 25 bucks with tax. Even with the dress being 8 not 2. She made me pay full price for both my clearance items and when I asked about the price she goes. Yea yea it’s right. I was so embarrassed I just left. I called the store later to tell the manager the situation and let them know it made me sad and was embarrassing. Eventually she admitted it was her and was very rude on the phone as well. I told her to be kinder to guests and hung up. Do better Plato’s and look for kinder customer service representatives👍🏼