Reynolds & Company Jewelers

Reviews

• BL

  Bailee Leonard

  1 day ago
  5.0
  The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful. A very welcoming place with amazing products. 100% would recommend if you’re looking for a new watch to your addition or new jewelry! Definitely worth checking out
• RI

  Randy I

  3 days ago
  5.0
  ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Fantastic experience at Reynolds & Company Jewelers on Park Avenue. I stopped in to look at a Tissot PRX, and David and Ryan were amazing. They were both incredibly knowledgeable, took the time to walk me through the different options, and made the whole experience feel relaxed with absolutely no pressure. You can tell they genuinely know watches and enjoy helping people find the right piece, rather than just trying to make a sale. Great service, great people, and exactly the kind of experience you hope for when shopping at a local jeweler. I’ll definitely be back!
• IC

  Interchained Core

  Sep 5, 2026
  5.0
  A beautiful place, a staple of park Ave. David Reynolds Jewelry is one of those special Park Avenue businesses that makes you feel genuinely welcome. David and his team are knowledgeable, kind, and always a pleasure to see. Beautiful jewelry, excellent service, and a great part of the Park Avenue community. Highly recommend!
• KH

  Kimberly Hammer

  Sep 3, 2026
  5.0
  Friendly and helpful. Had a problem with my son’s necklace, that was purchased somewhere else, and they fixed it super quickly. Beautiful collection of jewelry to shop for sure!
• LP

  Like Pavement

  Aug 25, 2026
  1.0
  Walked in off the street to see about a lady's Datejust. They kept calling it a presidential. I corrected them and they insist it’s the actually name of ladies Datejust. The inventory looked suspect. What do I know. I just have a $750k collection full of Patek, APs, and Rolex. Working with major jewelers like DavidSW. The shop looks fugazi. The employees are uninformed. They're blissfully ignorant. They had a bunch of "no box/no paper" watches priced higher than grey complete sets. Amateur. Don't buy from these children. Edit to respond: these watches are not for sale. lol I wanted to make clear how bad your inventory is compared to a personal collection. THERE’S a ladies DATEJUST and a DAYDATE. NO SUCH MODEL IN ROLEX’S CATALOG CALLED THE PRESIDENTIAL. That’s the nickname. The watch is vintage. Not rare.

Frequently Asked Questions About Reynolds & Company Jewelers