McCaskill & Company

Reviews

• KC

  Kirstie Carollo

  today
  5.0
  We love coming to McCaskill to buy our jewelry & we’re happy to see that Ryan is working here at McCaskill! He was awesome! We look forward to shopping with you guys again!
• CG

  christine glavine

  3 days ago
  5.0
  I recently worked with McCaskill & Company on several jewelry repairs, appraisals, and a custom project, and the experience has been exceptional from start to finish. They repaired some of my favorite pieces that had been sitting unworn for far too long, and the craftsmanship was outstanding. Their team has also been helping me source the perfect custom stone to repurpose a sentimental setting, and I truly appreciate the care and attention they’ve given every detail. Everyone there has been incredibly kind, professional, trustworthy, and attentive — always keeping me updated and personally calling when pieces were finished. It has been such a pleasure working with them, and I’m so happy to have a top-notch jeweler like this so close to home.
• CW

  Connie Welch

  4 days ago
  5.0
  I always love visiting McCaskill and Company! I recently stopped by for their expansion celebration to meet Designer and Gem Dealer Extraordinaire Kimberly Collins!! What a treat! Thank you Josh for always keeping me up to date on my favorite designers. You always have an amazing eye for detail and go the extra mile to find exactly what I’m looking for. The photos speak for themselves. I’m loving building my collection with you and the team at McCaskill and Co. I want to give a special THANK YOU to your new Wonder Bench-Woman Stella!! She is an amazing talent!! She was able to adjust a ring and pendant in a few minutes with great attention to detail! She is a true gem of an asset to McCaskills. Thank you all again. I love my new Lauren K pink and orange sapphire necklace and Kimberly Collin’s’ heart shaped pink spinel earrings!!! I’m also sending a shout out to Designer Erica Courtney - Still adoring your lovely rings!! I receive compliments on my ring stack daily!
• KW

  Kelly Waltemath

  May 11, 2026
  5.0
  Ken Kraft opened up with welcome arms when I came in looking for the perfect 35th birthday jewelry piece. He was kind, knowledgeable and not pushy. When I made my purchase, he made it feel special and celebratory. Thank you Ken!
• MD

  Mark Dutton

  May 6, 2026
  5.0
  I had an outstanding experience at McCaskill & Company in Destin, and I can’t recommend them enough. Josh helped me purchase my Rolex, and he made the entire process smooth, informative, and genuinely enjoyable. He took the time to answer all my questions, explained the details clearly, and never made me feel rushed or pressured. What really stood out was his professionalism and attention to detail. Buying a Rolex is a big decision, and Josh made sure I felt confident every step of the way. The level of customer service I received was top-notch, and it’s clear that they truly care about their clients. If you’re looking for a luxury watch or fine jewelry, definitely ask for Josh. I’ll absolutely be back for future purchases!

Frequently Asked Questions About McCaskill & Company