Plato's Closet

Reviews

• JK

  Jasmine Kaur

  5 days ago
  1.0
  If u are colored don’t go here!! If you are the owner please train staff with more customer service. Uncomfortable experience got weird glances from staff (5 girls) and were just staring at us when me and my cousins walked in the girl that was taking my clothes didn’t explain the rules properly and someone else had to explain them, didn’t take anything because said they don’t take clothes that are button down (too classy for them) fine, but half of them were sweaters and un worn jeans. It’s ok, donated them to goodwill instead, but really uncomfortable experience!!
• KF

  Kirstie Farrar

  Jun 13, 2026
  5.0
  Wonderful selection
• AG

  Alexis Grasdock

  Jun 10, 2026
  1.0
  I gave them an originally $120 dress from Oh Polly in great condition and they gave me less than $5 for it. What a scam. Don’t go here. If management sees this, please let me know if there’s any way to get my dress back and I’ll delete this review.
• JR

  Joseph Rossi

  May 21, 2026
  1.0
  Just wow to the whole experience here. Should have trusted the community. Stay away, this place is a headache was a waste of time. Maybe they only buy coach or Louis Vuitton lol all of my men’s brand name items like Nike or express rejected. That’s fine. Although having to come here 3 times to get that result all due to a reps inability to communicate how to bag my items first time (I called ahead of time, never mentioned.), then when buying times stop vs their operating business hours. This is my real frustration… 3 trips, all for nothing.. I’ve worked with other locations in the past (Still Plato’s, just different store), with my same clothing type and didn’t have any annoyance as opposed to the burden that this experience came with. Pay mind to the reason they’re 2.8!
• KK

  Katie Kreuter

  May 5, 2026
  2.0
  I really don't want to leave a bad review but I'm just so confused. I thought this place advertises that it pays you money on the spot for your clothes they take and turns out that isn't true. I went yesterday at 2pm and was told I'd have to pick up my items tomorrow and get my money then instead. I don't live around there but I said okay... So I went back today at 1:45 and brought in some more things to sell and again they told me no I'd have to come back tomorrow to get my money for the things I brought in. I don't understand. I don't live close by. Very confusing and frustrating.