Plato's Closet

Reviews

• KS

  kee shae

  Aug 23, 2026
  1.0
  GARBAGE. Lacks adequate customer service and workers with fashion/retail "Brand" experience. I do not recommend any members of any branch of the Armed Forces Army, Navy, Air Force, or Marines shop here or especially sell any items here. I brought in new shoes, clothing items and they basically tried to cheat me and offer $44 dollars. Whatever data base system there using to price used clothing, clearly should be re-evaluated and their Business Practices should be investigated by the Attorney General. Your workers need customer service training and training on Retail "BRAND" sales and "fair" consignment re-sale. This establishment is a NO-GO. As a Tuscaloosa Native the Mayor should focus on bringing much needed Branded stores and Malls for shopping not-pop up shops owned by friends outside investors who do not have the regular citizens of Tuscaloosa best interests. I'd rather see a GAP, American Eagle, H&M, Urban Outfitters, etc. that will serve ALL not just out of state UA students. Awful Experience
• CS

  Colby Sheehan

  Aug 17, 2026
  1.0
  Men's section is so unreasonably disorganized it's basically impossible to find anything in there. Would not recommend.
• TM

  Twa Moya

  Jul 17, 2026
  3.0
  Just ok, they never buy my items always saying overstock, I wear plus size and im thinking that's the reason, all my items were new never worn. I won't be back to this Platos. Just o.k.
• PP

  penelope

  Jun 10, 2026
  1.0
  employees are always rude but today an employee opened my door when i was in the try on room 💔 banged on the door then waited a split second before sticking her foot under after i said i was in there, i stuck my foot under as well and she cracked open the door??? ????? i closed the door on her hand buddy what are you doing. She didnt even say anything just walked away💔💔💔💔
• GH

  Gary Harton

  May 8, 2026
  1.0
  Customer service was disappointing. I wasn’t greeted, and when I spoke to associates, they ignored me. As a Black man, the experience felt unwelcoming and uncomfortable.