Garrick Jewelers

4.9
222 reviews

About

Jewelry StoreJewelry DesignerJewelerWedding JewelryPrecious & Semi-Precious StonesJewelry AppraiserDiamond DealerJewelry Repair ServiceSilversmithDiamonds
Adding Sparkle to Hanover, Pennsylvania Since 1993 Garrick Jewelers has offered our customers vast selection, unsurpassed service and the highest quality product lines. Our reputation is important to us, and it is our goal to remain the local, independent jeweler who offers more and who offers the best. Garrick Jeweler's co-founders, Rick Foye and Gary Bond, met while working together at a local jewelry store in the early 1980's. In 1993 they made the decision to branch out on their own and combined their names, their resources and their business experience to create Garrick Jewelers. In September, 2001 Garrick Jewelers relocated from the North Hanover Mall to their current location on Eichelberger Street. Their elegant, 5,000 square foot, freestanding store is a testament to the commitment Foye and Bond made to their community and each other over a decade ago.

Location

Garrick Jewelers
1117 Eichelberger St., Hanover, PA
17331, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.9
222 reviews
5 stars
212
4 stars
6
3 stars
1
2 stars
0
1 star
3

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Customer Service

Customers consistently praised the friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful staff, highlighting their willingness to go above and beyond.

Quality Repairs

Many reviews noted excellent experiences with jewelry repairs and restorations, often completed quickly and to a high standard.

Product Selection

The store offers a diverse and appealing selection of jewelry, with many customers expressing satisfaction in finding exactly what they were looking for.

Local Business Support

Customers appreciated the local, family-owned aspect of the business, often preferring it over larger retailers for its personalized service.

Mixed Experiences

While most feedback was positive, there were isolated incidents of dissatisfaction, particularly regarding watch repairs.
  • MN
    Matt Norris
    Oct 14, 2025
    5.0
    Rajen helped me find a watch that was perfect, however it was discontinued and unavailable through Garrick. I was able to source it elsewhere (online) that had some old stock. Once I received it, Rajen at Garrick sized the band and set the time day and date. Because Rajen was so helpful and Garrick’s prices are so very reasonable, I won’t shop around - Garrick will be my first and last stop. I just ordered a second watch through them. The price was very similar to online, but the watch comes with a lifetime of support when purchased through Garrick. It is so much better to buy local!
  • TB
    Theresa Bocklage
    Oct 13, 2025
    5.0
    I had a great experience with Garrick Jewelers. Bethany was super friendly and helpful. I took my ring to the jewelry store because it was too loose and spinning around. Bethany said if the ring guards don't work they can put beads inside the ring. This ring is sentimental. My husband gave me this ring for our 20th anniversary. I got 2 beads on my ring which was great. But I had a hard time putting over my knuckle. I finally got it on my finger. After 1/2 hour wearing it, I felt I should take it back fearing my finger would have swollen during the night. I went back to Garrick's. Another young lady helped me. Also helpful and friendly. She consulted with Bethany since she was helping me. She cut the ring off and said she will have it fixed and sand down the beads. Tomorrow, I get to pick it up. Thank you ladies.
  • KT
    Kaylyn Thomas
    Sep 26, 2025
    5.0
    Sarah helped my fiancé and I find the perfect wedding band for him. She was super patient and let him try on as many as he needed. Shop was super friendly and helpful!! Highly recommend.
  • AC
    Abbie Crone
    Feb 12, 2018
    5.0
    Amazing is all I can say about our experience with Garrick Jewelers. My fiance had a fabulous experience picking out my engagement ring, especially having gone to multiple other places and having disappointing and degrading experiences. Then when picking out wedding bands, Karissa went above and beyond helping with our unique visions. I would recommend Garrick's to anyone and everyone, especially if you're looking to get unique finds and great deals (their coupons are FABULOUS). Thank you for helping make our special day a little less stressful!
  • PT
    Peggy Trujillo-Lawrence
    Jun 21, 2017
    5.0
    I had seen but didn't buy, a beautiful ring that happened to be on sale. The ring nagged at my mind for a week or so. When I finally went in to buy it, the ring was gone. There was a young woman that worked there that saw me searching the cases. She asked if she could help. I described the ring to her and luckily she remembered it. She drew a picture of it and then for the next week searched through all of her sources to find it. Unfortunately the ring just couldn't be found but she came up with a few alternatives that were similar. She was so deligent in her search. I was very impressed with her and her employers for allowing her the time for me, a customer. I ended up buying a ring she found for me and am really happy with it!

Frequently Asked Questions About Garrick Jewelers

Where is Garrick Jewelers located?

Garrick Jewelers is located at 1117 Eichelberger St., Hanover, PA 17331, US.

What are the operating hours of Garrick Jewelers?

Garrick Jewelers is open Monday to Thursday from 10:00 AM to 6:00 PM, Friday from 10:00 AM to 8:00 PM, and Saturday from 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM. It is closed on Sundays.