Went in to exchange some jeans and I had taken the tags off. I had my receipt and the tags with me. When I was greeted I was told at first that I would not be able to return these. The manager had stated she would allow it this once. I was helped by a young gentleman to see if I could find another size but I could not find any others I liked. I took the pants back up to let them know they did not fit and I would return the ones I had. A new person was now at the register who informed me that I could return these. The manager had to again say I could this one time.
I was not aware of this policy with the tags being off of the merchandise. I thought the employees and manager were very rude. Not sure I will be back to this location or American Eagle. Was very disappointed at this visit since I’ve never in all the years I’ve shopped here had this type of experience.
SR
Samantha Riley
Sep 20, 2025
1.0
I had to ask for help. Nobody even said hi.
BW
Brayden Weishaar
Mar 18, 2023
3.0
Ok sorry to anyone who read my review but the store is still there google maps is just stupid so that’s my bad but I only give a 3 bc the product is great and all and they have A LOT of clearance which is always nice but I to have always felt like I was being overly watched in what I’m picking up and looking at and it may be because it was only me in the store this last time I went but it’s was weird. Would I go back for the clearance underwear YES they had a bunch of them but for anything else I’d just go to Hagerstown American eagle.
What types of products can I find at American Eagle Gettysburg?
You can find a variety of products including women's and men's clothing such as jeans, t-shirts, pants, shorts, tops, polos, shirts, sweaters, hoodies, outerwear, shoes, boots, sandals, accessories, and fragrance.
What are the store hours for American Eagle at Gettysburg Drive?
The store is open Monday through Saturday from 10:00 AM to 8:00 PM, and Sunday from 10:00 AM to 6:00 PM.
Does American Eagle at Gettysburg offer in-store pickup or curbside pickup?
Yes, American Eagle offers both in-store pickup and curbside pickup services.
What payment options are accepted at American Eagle Gettysburg?
The store accepts various payment options including Afterpay, American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Cash, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa.
Where is American Eagle located in Gettysburg?
American Eagle is located at 1863 Gettysburg Drive, Suite G 970, in the Outlet Shoppes At Gettysburg, Gettysburg, PA 17325.
What is the contact phone number for American Eagle Gettysburg?
You can reach the store at +1 717-337-9044.
Which nearby stores can I visit for women's clothing near American Eagle Gettysburg?
Nearby stores for women's clothing include Maurices, Torrid, Lane Bryant, TALBOTS, The Uniform Outlet, and Coach at the Outlet Shoppes at Gettysburg.
Are there any nearby stores specializing in shoes or sportswear near American Eagle Gettysburg?
Yes, adidas OUTLET STORE offers shoes and sportswear, and Torrid also has a shoe store component nearby.
What dining options are available near American Eagle Gettysburg?
You can enjoy food at Auntie Anne's Pretzels Gettysburg Village Factory Outlet or Chopsticks Express, a Chinese and Asian restaurant, both located nearby.
Can I explore gift shops or unique boutiques near American Eagle Gettysburg?
Yes, nearby gift shops and boutiques include Swit Sports, The Chick Clique Collective, Christmas Tree Hill, and Fly by Night Trading Company, offering a range of fashion accessories, gifts, and antiques.