Many customers reported poor service, with staff being unhelpful, rude, or inattentive during their visits.
Product Availability
Customers frequently noted issues with stock levels, including empty shelves and items not being available despite online listings.
Store Atmosphere
The store's location in a nearly abandoned mall negatively impacted the shopping experience, with some describing it as unwelcoming.
Selection and Pricing
While some customers appreciated the variety and competitive prices, others felt the selection was lacking, particularly in specific categories like firearms and footwear.
Staffing Issues
Numerous reviews highlighted a consistent problem with understaffing, leading to long wait times and difficulty in receiving assistance.
DA
Don Ant
Nov 16, 2025
4.0
Nice store just a little bit disappointed driving all the way from Baltimore. Located in a dead mall
DW
Dennis Walters
Oct 18, 2025
3.0
Ok place, princes are ok location needs to move to a higher traffic are. Overall it was ok. Staff was nice 👍
TP
Thomas Polcha
Oct 15, 2025
5.0
Great
IY
Ibrahim Yousif
Sep 20, 2025
1.0
We had a disappointing experience at this store. We came to the store yesterday and as soon as we walked in, a fellow customer gave us an unwelcoming stare while checking out. When a customer service representative approached us, he seemed more interested in telling us what we couldn't have rather than assisting us. He repeatedly stated that they didn't have cleats in our son's size without giving us the opportunity to browse on our own. His behavior came across as dismissive and made us feel uncomfortable. He hovered over us until we left the store, which only added to our frustration.
I came today morning to get cleats for my other son, and I found shelf is empty. The same worker told me the they were shipped back and they are no longer selling cleats!
OR
Oualisaou Rachid
Sep 14, 2025
1.0
I went to this shop because they’re close to my home and their website showed a lot of handguns in my price range. I picked out a Taurus G3 that was in the glass display case. When I examined it in the store I noticed wear on the barrel hood and asked the clerk if it was used. He said it was new and hadn’t been fired that the marks were from customers racking the slide I asked whether they had an unboxed new unit he went to check and returned after a minute saying they didn’t. I trusted him and bought the one in the case
When I got home I discovered the firearm had clearly been fired one of the magazines had powder marks and the cartridge seating areas showed firing marks. This was sold to me as NEW when it was not I’m very disappointed and will not be coming back.
Apparel, Footwear, Workwear, Hunting, Guns, Ammo, Hunting Licenses, Archery, Fitness (including equipment), Golf, Boats, Camping, Fishing, Fishing Licenses, Baseball, Basketball, Football, Hockey, Soccer, Racket Sports, Facemasks, Essential items, Bicycles, Bowling, Boxing, Hiking, Disc Golf, Skating, Lacrosse, Games, Toys, Volleyball, Water Sports, Denim/Jeans, Winter Sports, Sleds, Wrestling, Yoga, Licensed Gear (NCAA, MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL etc.), Gift Cards and more! See https://www.dunhamssports.com/ for more.
What brands does Dunham's carry?
BIG NAMES- Nike, Under Armour, adidas, Yeti, Carhartt, Champion, Fila, Levi's, Wrangler, Skechers, Icon, Marcy, Pro-Form, Pelican, Remington, Smith & Wesson, Federal, Winchester, Taurus, KL Industries, Callaway, Titleist, Columbia, Crosman, Easton, Wilson, Champro, Rawlings, Huffy, Spalding, Pure Fishing, Oakley, Roxy, Quiksilver, Puma, and many more at LOW PRICES.
What are the operating hours of Dunham's Sports in Carlisle?
Dunham's Sports is open Monday to Saturday from 10:00 AM to 9:00 PM, and on Sunday from 12:00 PM to 5:00 PM.
Does Dunham's Sports offer in-store pickup or delivery services?
No, Dunham's Sports does not offer pickup or delivery services at this location.
What types of products can I find at Dunham's Sports?
You can find apparel, footwear, hunting gear, guns, ammo, archery equipment, fitness gear, golf, boats, camping, fishing gear, sports equipment for baseball, basketball, football, hockey, soccer, and more.
Which major brands are available at Dunham's Sports?
Dunham's carries big names like Nike, Under Armour, Adidas, Remington, Yeti, Easton, Fila, Champion, Carhartt, Crosman, Columbia, Federal, Icon, Levi's, Oakley, Ruger, Smith & Wesson, and Skechers.
Where is Dunham's Sports located?
Dunham's Sports is located at 800 E. High St., Ste. 470, Carlisle, PA 17013, USA, inside The Point at Carlisle Plaza.
What payment methods does Dunham's Sports accept?
Dunham's Sports accepts American Express, Cash, Check, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa.
Are there any COVID-19 related store changes at Dunham's Sports?
Yes. For the latest COVID-19 store changes, please visit https://www.dunhamssports.com/covid-19.html.
What nearby places can I visit before or after shopping at Dunham's Sports?
Near Dunham's Sports, you can visit The Point at Carlisle Plaza shopping center, Bath & Body Works for beauty products, and Momma Spriggs Restaurant for American and Mexican cuisine.
Are there health and wellness options close to Dunham's Sports?
Yes, nearby you can find GNC and GNC Live Well for vitamins and supplements, along with Carlisle Tae Kwon Do & Fitness Academy for martial arts and fitness activities.
Can I find other retail and service businesses near Dunham's Sports?
Yes, there are various nearby businesses including Bon-Ton department store, Royer's Flowers and Gifts, Lowe's Home Improvement, and UPS Access Point for courier services.