Brand Certified
Play it Again Sports Hilliard
4.4(272 reviews)
Certified by Play it Again Sports Hilliard • Mar 01, 2026
Business Details
4720 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, OH
43026, United States
Certified by Play it Again Sports Hilliard • Mar 01, 2026
(614) 529-9100
Certified by Play it Again Sports Hilliard • Mar 01, 2026
https://playitagainsports.com/locations/hilliard-oh/
Certified by Play it Again Sports Hilliard • Mar 01, 2026
About
Certified by Play it Again Sports Hilliard • Mar 01, 2026
Sporting Goods StoreSportswear StoreHockey Supply StoreExercise Equipment StoreGolf Equipment ShopBicycle Store
At Play It Again Sports Hilliard, we specialize in fitness, football, baseball, softball, golf, lacrosse, and hockey equipment. When it comes to the equipment you need, new or used, we are your premier sporting goods store in Hilliard, OH. We provide the best-fit sports gear that athletes need to play their games, from hockey skates to lacrosse sticks. It's our job and pride to ensure this equipment is right for you and your sport - and most importantly, that it performs for you. Our lineup of sporting equipment includes plenty of top brand-name options. And if you have some used equipment that's in good condition and no longer need it, get in touch! We're proud to offer top dollar for your used equipment. Visit us today!
Details
- DeliveryAvailable
- Requires appointmentNot available
- DebitAvailable
- Cash onlyNot available
Location
Certified by Play it Again Sports Hilliard • Mar 01, 2026
Hours
Certified by Play it Again Sports Hilliard • Mar 01, 2026
Reviews
4.4
272 reviews
5 stars
185
4 stars
49
3 stars
10
2 stars
7
1 star
21
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Customer Service
Many customers praised the staff for being helpful, knowledgeable, and accommodating, with specific mentions of employees like Owen, Chad, and Sally.
Product Selection
The store offers a wide variety of new and used sports equipment, with many customers noting the great selection and fair prices.
Negative Experiences
Some customers reported rude behavior from certain staff members and issues with the store's organization and cleanliness.
Pricing Concerns
While many found prices fair, some customers expressed dissatisfaction with the buying prices for used equipment, feeling they were too low.
- BRBeth RodabaughFeb 21, 20265.0I went in looking for a decent baseball glove and bat for my son with a little knowledge of what I was actually looking for. Owen, the gentleman working that day, was more than helpful when we were trying to figure out what bat size was needed. We will definitely be back.
- RMRobert MackeyFeb 7, 20265.0Very helpful and accommodating manager. Fair prices and fair payout for selling used equipment. Perfect place for equipment, especially with growing kids.
- CHColin HayesJan 30, 20261.0First of all they were very disrespectful and did not give us a reason for why they were angry, the guy with the mustache seemed to have some issues with the way we spoke but he didn’t give us any information about anything and proceeded to curse at us instead of using a kind tone. The mustache man also seemed to be into us because he followed us immediately when we went in. Their “junk” section was supposedly blocked off with no sign? The store in general was messy and I felt like I was in an episode of the “hoarders”. I have been there a good amount of times and never saw these employees before and this was clearly my worst experience. The younger worker with the mustache seems to be young and it might be his first job so you guys might want to teach him about how to be employed so you won’t have to deal with bad reviews like this. I wholeheartedly think if you got rid of the few bad apples who clearly have personality issues this store would be amazing, I still think this is a good store but some of the employees need to get their act together. Thank you!
- GGGio GalloJan 30, 20261.0Staff was very rude and weird following us around and the store is overall a mess. Got cussed at for absolutely no reason and i know when i deserve to be yelled at and that was not one. Go to another place this is not worth your time or experience terrible everything.
- KDKatie DingmanJan 27, 20265.0Found skis and boots for less than what it would’ve cost me to rent them twice! Store was very organized. Owen was so helpful and patient - thank you! I will definitely be back!
Frequently Asked Questions About Play it Again Sports Hilliard
Do you also sell new sporting goods?
Yes, while most of our store is gently-used sports equipment, we do have some brand new options as well!
Do you take hockey skates?
Sure do!
Do you sell equipment for snow sports?
Yes, we carry snowboards and skis along with bindings, boots, ski poles, helmets, snow pants, and more!
Do you buy sporting goods?
Yes! If you have equipment you don't use, we'll take it off your hands in exchange for cash or store credit!
How much do you pay for baseball gloves?
For all equipment you are selling, we first need to see it in person for a quality check before we give a quote.
Do you offer skate sharpening?
Yes! Bring in your skates and we'll give them a new edge.
Do you sell used bikes?
Yes, we carry both bicycles and stationary exercise bikes.
Can I buy all necessary football equipment?
Certainly! We carry everything needed to get you geared up for football season, including helmets, pads, cleats, and cleats!
Where are you located?
You can find us at 4720 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026.
Do you sell lacrosse equipment?
Yes, we carry lacrosse sticks, helmets, pads, and everything else you need for the season!
Do you re-grip golf clubs?
Yes, we do offer club regripping. Bring in your clubs and we'll get them ready for the links!
Do you sell wrestling gear?
Yes, we carry wrestling head gear, kneepads, and shoes.
Do you sell skis?
Yes, we carry skis, ski poles, and snow apparel.
Do you sell both new and used sporting goods?
Yes, we offer both gently-used sports equipment and some brand new options.
Can I sell my used sporting goods at Play it Again Sports Hilliard?
Yes! We buy used equipment in good condition and offer cash or store credit in exchange.
Do you provide skate sharpening services?
Yes, bring in your skates and we will sharpen them for you.
What kind of sports equipment do you specialize in?
We specialize in fitness, football, baseball, softball, golf, lacrosse, and hockey equipment.
Where is Play it Again Sports Hilliard located?
We are located at 4720 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026.
What are your store hours?
We are open Monday to Friday from 10:00am to 8:00pm, Saturday from 10:00am to 6:00pm, and Sunday from 12:00pm to 5:00pm.
Which payment options do you accept?
We accept American Express, Apple Pay, cash, Discover, and Visa.
Are there any nearby dining options I can visit after shopping?
Yes, nearby you can find Grand China, an Asian restaurant, and Citadel Cafe, a cozy spot for coffee and snacks.
What nearby fitness or sports instruction places can I check out?
Close by is the Hilliard ATA Martial Arts school offering martial arts classes, and Northwest School of Dance for performing arts.
What other nearby businesses might be helpful to visit while in the area?
Nearby you can find The UPS Store for shipping needs, Fisher BMV for vehicle services, and MK Exteriors for roofing and construction services.
Brand Certified Facts from Play it Again Sports Hilliard
Play it Again Sports Hilliard partners directly with Yext to publish this data from the brand's official system of record. Learn more about our data sources
Certified March 01, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
- Address
- Categories
- Geo coordinates
- Legal business name
- Hours of operation
- Phone number
- Official website