Feedback on customer service is mixed; while some associates received high praise for their helpfulness and attentiveness, others were reported as rude or dismissive.
Store Atmosphere
The store is generally described as clean and well-organized, with a nice vibe, but some customers felt uncomfortable due to aggressive staff behavior.
Product Availability
Customers appreciated the variety of products and sales, but there were complaints about stock issues and disorganization in finding sizes.
Staff Recognition
Several reviews highlighted specific employees for their exceptional service, suggesting a need for management to recognize and reward these individuals.
ML
Michela L
Jan 18, 2026
5.0
I came to this location yesterday in desperate need of activewear and Kaylee on the 3rd floor helped me so much! She was so sweet and knowledgeable about Offline and gave me great advice on the best colors for my skin tone and best pieces for my various activities. Best Aerie I’ve ever been to THANK YOU KAYLEE
IR
Isabella Reyes
Dec 30, 2025
5.0
I have never been to this location before but I went for the first time a few days ago and i truly feel that this associate deserves recognition.
I was having the worst day possible, it felt like things were coming at me from every direction, but when I walked into that store, everything shifted. The associate who helped me (from what I recall, her name was Melina) greeted me with so much kindness and patience and instantly made me feel comfortable.
I thought I was just going to look around, but she really took the time to help me. She recommended things I ended up loving and explained everything so clearly, you could tell she really knew what she was talking about. She even helped me while managing multiple guests at once, and somehow still made me feel like a priority the entire time. She told me exactly what to look for on every floor despite her being on the 1st floor. She was such a strong selling leader I left with 4 leggings, 2 bras, and matching underwear, all from her recommendations, and I’m so glad I did. She walked me through every product and made sure I felt confident, NEVER pressured which I value deeply when it comes to shopping.
Melina was so incredibly attentive, and such a strong selling leader. Because of her, I walked out not only with great pieces but in a much better mood. Aerie, please notice her. She’s a valuable part of the team and absolutely deserves some type of real recognition, even a promotion, because she truly made an impact on my day that I never thought someone could. Thank you! Everyone else was also nice.
TB
Tristan B
Dec 4, 2025
1.0
Came in here for a robe as a gift. Would have loved some help- someone else got helped and then I got walked by a bunch of times, no welcome or asking if I needed something despite being in the store for about 10 minutes. Just kind of put me off the experience!
LO
Leonela Obregon
May 31, 2025
1.0
TERRIBLE COSTUMER SERVICE AT THE LEXINGTON AVE LOCATION
I went in to pick up my order , they treated me badly. They gave me the damn order without a cover or anything, the worst customer service. I bought a lot but with this I won't even buy anymore
What types of products does American Eagle offer at the Lexington Avenue store?
American Eagle offers a variety of products including women's and men's clothing, jeans, t-shirts, pants, shorts, tops, polos, shirts, sweaters, hoodies, outerwear, shoes, boots, sandals, accessories, and fragrance.
What are the operating hours for American Eagle on Lexington Avenue?
The store is open from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM Monday through Saturday, and from 11:00 AM to 7:00 PM on Sundays. It is closed on November 27, 2025, with special hours on subsequent holiday dates.
Does the American Eagle store on Lexington Avenue offer in-store pickup services?
Yes, this location offers in-store pickup for your convenience.
What payment options are accepted at the American Eagle on Lexington Avenue?
They accept Afterpay, American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Cash, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa.
Where is the American Eagle store on Lexington Avenue located?
It is located at 716 718 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10022, United States.
Does American Eagle on Lexington Avenue have an official website and social media?
Yes, their website is https://storelocations.ae.com/us/ny/new-york/02414-716-718-lexington-ave.html, Facebook page at https://www.facebook.com/165177124044103, Instagram handle @americaneagle, and Twitter handle @AEO.
Are there other clothing stores near American Eagle on Lexington Avenue?
Yes, nearby clothing stores include another American Eagle Outfitters location and Aerie, both offering women's and men's clothing options.
What dining options are available near American Eagle on Lexington Avenue?
Pollo Campero, a chicken restaurant and diner, is nearby and a great option for a meal before or after shopping.
Are there any healthcare providers close to the American Eagle store?
Yes, there are several nearby healthcare providers including New Dimension Dentistry, Allergy & Asthma Care of New York, O’Dwyer & Colavito Primary Eye Care, and Bochner Chiropractic and Sports Injury Care.
What is the store's policy during holidays?
American Eagle on Lexington Avenue is closed on November 27, 2025. The store will have special hours from 10:00 AM to 8:00 PM on November 28 and 29, 2025.
Brand Certified Facts from American Eagle
American Eagle partners directly with Yext to publish this data from the brand's official system of record. Learn more about our data sources
Certified March 01, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: