Goodwill - Mt. Island

Reviews

• KC

  Katie C

  Feb 2, 2026
  1.0
  This used to be my favorite go to goodwill. But their prices lately have been INSANE way too high.. Who ever is pricing the items needs to figure it out. -responding to comment: you make plenty of money. No reason a box of McDonald’s toys and broken toys should be $40! A broken lamp $15, art work from target marked 19.99. This stuff is donated and not brand new! Are they getting commission for the amount of sales?! No reason to price peoples donated crap so high
• NB

  Nicholas Bradford

  Jan 3, 2026
  5.0
  Excellent Goodwill with a nice blend of clothes household items and toys.
• WW

  wtb

  Jan 1, 2026
  1.0
  I don’t know what Tammy’s problem is in the donation department, I understand if they’re not taking certain donations due to space but she is super rude. There’s something wrong with her fr
• UR

  undercover review

  Oct 23, 2025
  1.0
  This is really insane the lack of management skills this store has! Shoutout to Shelly for caring about her staff members but the Store manager Lakechic, and 2 assistants Mark and Lemitch, only care about themselves and saving themselves. It is soooo sad to get rid of amazing, hard-working, and respectful staff member but saving your own self when you're doing wrong. I only come to this store because of the 2 young amazing DP's - Anthony and Mar & all of the respectful young ladies at the front register. I've seen first hand, management ignoring their employees and taking their time to help them out when needed. There's even been a time where one cashier was working herself too much and the managers didn't budge to help. This store needs to be looked into, especially with those 3 managers. I even know that one looks at all the young girls in the store, some have left due to this. The store manager, Lakechic Hearn, didn't care much about the young girl leaving but more so of keeping Lemitch. Shaking my prayers, hope this gets looked into.
• ED

  E. Dingle

  Sep 18, 2025
  1.0
  I stopped in to return an item purchased from another location. It took over 10 minutes for the heavy set man to get to the register. He clearly did not want to honor the company's return policy. A few weeks earlier I purchased an armoire as a gift for someone. I borrowed a truck and returned the following day to pick-up. To my great disappointment, after waiting over 15 minutes, I learned that my item had been sold to another. Eventually a female, I believe she was a supervisor, said she watched the video footage and saw that another customer paid for the same item shortly after me that same day. It then took an additional 10 minutes for a young man to get to the register to return what I had paid to my credit card. Apathy and lack of efficiency evidently lives here.

Frequently Asked Questions About Goodwill - Mt. Island