American Eagle Outfitters in Louisville, KY is a brand with expertly crafted, high quality jeans at our core. We create clothes that fit our customers lives, all made to take and make your own. We fit everyone. Visit your local American Eagle Outfitters at 5000 Shelbyville Road today.
Let me just preface this review with the fact that this story isn’t directly about me, so I don’t need a response from the business apologizing to me. I am speaking up for the young lady who was trying on clothes herself. I am writing this to spread awareness that people have views that are all over, so despite someone’s reasoning not making since to you, it could to someone else. I was in the store around 1:15 today, so you can use this for reference when you hopefully address this with your employees working the fitting room. I was trying on clothes when I heard someone talking (with judgement) about what clothing sizes a young lady picked to try on. She was complaining about the fact that someone chose sizes 8,10, and 12. The tone of the conversation was negative because she was upset about having someone’s clothes to put back. Saying things like “who would need this many sizes” and “I bet she didn’t even try all of them on”. My response to that is first off, you’re rude for commenting about someone’s sizes when you don’t even know if she’s still in the fitting room and/or store. Next, you are being paid to do a fitting room job. If you don’t like it then go find another job that suits your likes and dislikes better. No one is holding you hostage. Finally, have you stopped to think that she, like many of us, could have gained a little weight and was struggling to find a size that fits her body given the new fall season? Why make comments with your own rude judgement that could discourage someone from finding clothes that make them feel good in their own body? I find it quite relatable to pick out a few sizes and see what you like. At the end of the day, despite the differing opinion you might have, you are paid to put clothes away. Maybe do the bare minimum and remember we are all human and do things for our own reasons. Leave the judgmental comments at home and make the store a place where people can feel good getting something new. Without customers, you don’t have a job. It’s a shame that kindness is now a skill that has to be taught on the job, but that’s the way it is. Be better American Eagle employees.
AJ
amy johnson
Sep 25, 2025
1.0
I’m from out of town and wanted to try a new pair of Jeans. The staff didn’t welcome me or try to help me find anything. I’ve never been in an american eagle and was lost. When i proceeded to ask for help they were incredibly rude, they gave me dirty looks and scoffed at me. The staff was also smoking in the fitting room which is highly inappropriate.
VG
Virginia Glass
Sep 10, 2025
5.0
Kaitlyn and Nicole were so helpful with sizing and shipping questions. Made my day so much easier
MA
Megan Ahlgrim
Aug 23, 2025
5.0
Kelsey is the best!! She was so helpful and kind <3
JR
Jay Rogers
Jul 27, 2025
5.0
Nothing different from the usual AE. I liked that my birthday deal was honored. 5/5
Frequently Asked Questions About American Eagle & Aerie
What types of products can I find at American Eagle & Aerie in Louisville, KY?
You can find a wide range of products including women's and men's clothing, jeans, t-shirts, pants, shorts, tops, polos, shirts, sweaters, hoodies, outerwear, shoes, boots, sandals, accessories, fragrance, bras, underwear, sleepwear, swimwear, and yoga pants.
What are the store hours for American Eagle & Aerie on weekdays?
The store is open Monday through Saturday from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM, and on Sunday from 12:00 PM to 6:00 PM.
Does American Eagle & Aerie offer in-store pickup services?
Yes, American Eagle & Aerie offers in-store pickup services as well as curbside pickup and in-store shopping.
Where is the American Eagle & Aerie store located in Louisville?
The store is located at 5000 Shelbyville Road, Suite 1700, Louisville, KY 40207 inside Mall St Matthews.
What payment methods are accepted at American Eagle & Aerie?
They accept American Express, Apple Pay, Cash, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa.
Are there any nearby food options where I can grab a bite before or after shopping?
Yes, nearby you can find Diego's Mexican Grill, Maki Of Japan, Ruby Thai Kitchen, Tumbleweed Tex Mex Grill & Margarita Bar, Subway, Freakin' Unbelievable Burgers, Charleys Cheesesteaks, RedBrick Pizza, Chick-fil-A, and Kung Fu Tea for various dining options.
What other shopping options are near American Eagle & Aerie?
Nearby shopping includes Agape Fashion Co., Dry Goods, PacSun, Louisville Stoneware Co., The Buckle, Buckle, another American Eagle store, and Aerie.
Are there beauty and personal care services close to American Eagle & Aerie?
Yes, customers can visit Girlfriends Nail Shoppe, MR Dee Barber/ Cosmetologist, Terry Da Barber, pinecone piercing, and Transformason’s Barber Studio SMP/PMU nearby for beauty and grooming services.
Is the American Eagle & Aerie store open during holidays?
The store is closed on Thanksgiving Day (2025-11-27) and Christmas Day (2025-12-25). It has special holiday hours on Black Friday and other select dates; for example, open 9:00 AM to 9:00 PM on 2025-11-28 and 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM on 2025-12-24.
How can I contact American Eagle & Aerie in Louisville for more information?
You can reach them by phone at +1 502-895-1071 or visit their website at https://storelocations.ae.com/us/ky/louisville/02245-5000-shelbyville-road.html.