Reynolds & Company Jewelers

4.8
26 reviews

About

Jewelry StoreJewelry AppraiserJewelry Repair ServiceDiamondsJewelry Designer
Reynolds & Co. Jewelers is a trusted custom jeweler and premier jewelry store proudly serving Winter Park, FL. We specialize in elegant women's necklaces, bracelets, rings, earrings, wedding bands, and engagement rings, as well as refined men's necklaces, bracelets, rings, and wedding bands. Our expert services include watch repairs and professional appraisals. Voted Jeweler of the Year by Orlando Style Magazine in October 2019, we are known for quality craftsmanship and personalized attention. Whether you're celebrating a milestone or upgrading your collection, find something truly unique with us. Visit today or call to schedule your consultation. Experience excellence at Reynolds & Co. Jewelers.

Details

  • DeliveryAvailable
  • DebitAvailable
  • Mobile paymentsAvailable
  • Accepts checksAvailable

Location

Reynolds & Company Jewelers
232 North Park Avenue, Winter Park, FL
32789, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.7
17 reviews
5 stars
15
4 stars
1
3 stars
0
2 stars
0
1 star
1
  • PP
    Paul
    Sep 6, 2025
    5.0
    If you need jewelry appraised and/or have a jewelry stash of questionable valuable, Reynolds and Co. Jewelers is the place to go! I spoke to twelve stores who review and appraise jewelry in the central Florida area and decided on Reynolds and Co. due to their substantial experience with all types of jewelry, having a graduate gemologist onsite and very reasonable rates. Owner David spent a significant amount of time with us reviewing our jewelry. David provided insights on each piece and was very patient answering our many questions. At our request David provided candid recommendations and was never pushy to make a sale or steer us in a disadvantageous direction. Susan expertly performed appraisals on a number of pieces generating a document containing pictures, detailed information and a value assessment of each. Susan’s highly comprehensive analysis identified unknown information on a few of the pieces, ironically never noted in previous appraisals from other stores. Reynolds and Co. also sized two rings (expertly matching an intricate design so one could never tell!) and made a highly creative suggestion combining parts from two of our pieces with exceptional results. Thank you David and Susan, you are a blessing!
  • CJ
    Christopher Jensen
    Dec 9, 2021
    5.0
    Amazing experience my wife Lilly is so happy! She told me how down to earth and professional they where. She is all set for the best Christmas ever with her dream ring! Thank you!!
  • ZF
    Zack Frapart
    Apr 2, 2021
    5.0
    Awesome people. Worked hard and earned my business for what I was looking for!
  • SO
    Steve Olson
    Sep 11, 2020
    5.0
    I did a consignment with them and it was a great experience. They were honest, ethical, and I'd have no hesitation buying or consigning with them again. GREAT WORK Reynolds &Co!

Frequently Asked Questions About Reynolds & Company Jewelers

Where is Reynolds & Company Jewelers located?

Reynolds & Company Jewelers is located at 232 North Park Avenue, Winter Park, FL 32789, USA.

What are the store hours of Reynolds & Company Jewelers?

The store is open Tuesday through Saturday from 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM and closed on Sundays and Mondays.