Customers consistently praised the exceptional customer service, highlighting the professionalism, knowledge, and attentiveness of the staff.
Sales Experience
Many reviews noted positive experiences during the purchasing process, with specific mentions of staff members who provided personalized assistance and made customers feel valued.
Product Knowledge
Staff demonstrated extensive knowledge about the products, helping customers make informed decisions and enhancing their overall shopping experience.
Management Issues
A few reviews pointed out issues with management, particularly regarding pricing errors and lack of accountability, which negatively impacted some customers' experiences.
Overall Satisfaction
Despite some negative feedback, the majority of customers expressed high satisfaction with their experiences, often returning for future purchases.
CW
C W
Jan 5, 2026
5.0
Great store very professional. I have several Daytonas and I just ordered a new one. Hopefully, I’ll see you in a year or two but no rush. Great customer service.
KR
Kallie Reid
Dec 29, 2025
5.0
Very friendly and professional employees, great experience! Wide selection of watches and jewelry
DM
daisy muenzner
Dec 24, 2025
5.0
Excellent and very professional, did not forget us so excited we waitlisted and she contact me like she said she would we she received one and I'm the proud owner of a lavender 36m stainless watch. Love this store!
AR
Amber Reyes
Dec 23, 2025
5.0
We were lucky enough to with Declan on purchasing a big wishlist item that we had our eye on. The communication throughout the search, service at Mayors, and follow up was nothing short of phenomenal. We are looking forward to continuing our relationship and purchasing more pieces in the future.
TC
Tommy Cheung
Dec 6, 2025
1.0
I went to Mayors today with intentions on buying a watch. Josephine who was very nice and helpful was my salesperson. I was sold on breitling, she explained the difference between Tudor and breitling, she sold me on Tudor. She showed me the chronomat and I agreed to buy it. She said it was on sale and the tag had a dot. She gave me the price and was ringing it up. Something happened and she called manager over, then she informed me it was a mistake and the manager would not honor the sale price. The manager was very unprofessional and had nothing to say, not even apologetic just a blank stare . He offered a watchwinder for a watch I did not buy. If they put a dot on the tag showing it on sale they should honor it, mistake or not we were finalizing the sale. If they have a sale , management should review the sales items to ensure they are correct. Please call to discuss, you have my number. I went back last nite and met with regional manager Sarah. I really liked the watch they quoted me on, so I went ahead and purchased at the NEW price they gave WHICH was not the original price they quoted. Even though they were wrong, they did NOT honor their original price. This is not a place of honesty and integrity. Customer relationships is not important to them, I would recommend shopping elsewhere. I am posting to all of Mayors stores to show their professionalism. This is about intergerity and honesty, not about the price of the watch. That's why I paid more than what was quoted. Real shady organization.
Mayors is located at 4834 River City Drive, Suite #119, Jacksonville, FL 32246, USA.
What are the operating hours of Mayors?
Mayors is open Monday to Thursday from 10:00 AM to 7:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 10:00 AM to 8:00 PM, and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 6:00 PM.
What products does Mayors specialize in?
Mayors specializes in watches and jewelry.
Does Mayors offer in-store shopping and pickup?
Yes, Mayors offers both in-store shopping and in-store pickup options.
Is there wheelchair accessible parking at Mayors?
Yes, Mayors has wheelchair accessible parking available.
How can I contact Mayors?
You can contact Mayors by calling +1 904-564-1972.
Where can I find more information or shop online for Mayors?
You can visit their website at https://www.mayors.com/.
Which nearby jewelry stores are close to Mayors?
Nearby jewelry stores include Tiffany & Co. and Omega Watches, which you might visit for additional luxury jewelry and watch options.
Are there dining options near Mayors for before or after your visit?
Yes, nearby dining options include Cantina Laredo for Tex-Mex cuisine, BurgerFi for fast food, and The Capital Grille for American steakhouse fare.
What other shopping experiences can I explore near Mayors?
Around Mayors, you can visit Louis Vuitton for fashion accessories, Forever 21 for clothing, and Apple St. Johns Town Center for electronics and mobile phones.