Inconceivable Toys & Games in Castle Rock

Reviews

• NB

  Nancy Berbrin

  Dec 16, 2025
  1.0
  Do not sell your cards here! During a difficult period in my life, I was dealing with a sick pet and selling personal items to help cover veterinary expenses. I attempted to sell Pokémon cards at this location. My first experience went smoothly; however, the second visit was extremely disappointing. I brought in a stack of older cards in good condition and was initially quoted approximately $700 by them. After reviewing the cards, the employee informed me that he only had $200 in cash available because they had not been to the bank. When I asked why the quoted amount had changed, I was told that he would not be going to the bank for a few days. Due to this inconsistency, I chose to take my cards and leave. Based on this experience, I would not recommend this business. I encourage others to consider the reputable card shops in Castle Rock instead, such as House of Cards Sports & TCG and Hidden Gemz, which I have found to be more transparent and trustworthy.
• AJ

  Aurie Jarrell

  Dec 5, 2025
  5.0
  Very cool game store! It’s always fun browsing and shopping for new games!
• KD

  Kyler Durrant

  Jan 10, 2023
  5.0
  Great place with friendly staff and an amazing owner. Wide selection of paints and minis for those into Warhammer, with good prices to go along with it. I forgot to get the name of the associate who helped me, but she was very nice and recommended some great paints and tips for me. Definitely a amazing place for those who are new or experienced with miniatures!
• MB

  Melissa Bachmann

  Jan 29, 2022
  5.0
  I was very impressed with this game store. The staff was helpful, and they have a good selection of games/miniatures for purchase as well as lots of table space for playing games. If you're a (physical games not video) gamer you should come check them out.