The Reserve at Sugarloaf

Reviews

• QQ

  Queen

  Apr 30, 2026
  2.0
  I recently toured this community after traveling from New York specifically to view apartments in the area, & while the unit itself was nice, my overall experience was disappointing. The leasing experience felt very transactional and not welcoming. When I arrived, there wasn’t much engagement, and I wasn’t even introduced to the leasing agent. I had to ask for her name at the end of the tour. Her name was Aubrei. The tour itself felt rushed, & I didn’t feel like there was much effort to provide a thorough or personable experience. I also asked to see an unfurnished unit, but was told they “look the same” instead of being shown one, which made the experience feel even more limited. What stood out the most is that I toured multiple communities during my trip, and the difference in customer service was very clear. Other leasing teams were warm, personable, & genuinely welcoming, which made a big difference in how I felt about those communities. The apartment itself is nice, which is why I’m giving 2 stars instead of 1, but the leasing experience did not match the quality of the property. I would recommend improving customer service & overall engagement with prospective residents.
• RA

  Rhonda Anderson

  Feb 24, 2026
  1.0
  I had been a resident of The Reserve at Sugarloaf for over nine years, and this has been one of the most disappointing experiences I have ever had with a property management company. My personal belongings were placed into the property’s storage area and were subsequently lost or removed, with no explanation and no accountability. I still possess the original storage key, which I have had since I moved in, yet management has failed to provide any meaningful response, investigation, or resolution regarding what happened to my property. Even more concerning has been the unprofessional and dismissive behavior from onsite management. Rather than empathy or assistance, I was met with a hostile attitude when trying to resolve a serious issue involving my personal belongings. After nearly a decade of residency, this level of disregard is unacceptable. This experience clearly demonstrates a lack of oversight, transparency, and respect for long-term residents. I would strongly caution prospective tenants to consider how issues are handled here—particularly when something goes wrong and accountability is required.
• AP

  Atlantic Property

  Feb 24, 2026
  5.0
  Awesome management and staff service!
• MJ

  madiha jannat

  Feb 11, 2026
  5.0
  The management staff are very helpful. All mintenance complaints are answered very quickly. Place is beautiful and clean. Thank you for given such a wonderful experience
• AM

  Austin Marmontello

  Dec 18, 2025
  5.0
  Aubrie has been nothing short of amazing throughout my whole process. She actively listened and really helped meet my needs. My small interaction with other staff was great as well.

Frequently Asked Questions About The Reserve at Sugarloaf