VERY unprofessional! She wanted to charge way above commission average because of the property size. RED FLAG RUN far from this company!
SM
Sarah Myers
Mar 18, 2025
1.0
Terrible appraisal service and very unprofessional. Appraised a home for a friend well above the homes worth at the home was in deplorable shape. This effected a court case. After the court case a month later that same realtor listed that same home for $45,000 less. Look for any other real estate agency when looking for a local agency.
RM
Rebecca Maciag
Mar 9, 2021
5.0
I worked with Steve when selling my house. He was very candid and patient with me through the whole process. He worked with me until the final papers were signed and made it all an easy experience.
ST
Scott Thomas
Feb 16, 2021
1.0
Terrible appraisal service! First thing they tell me is my home is hard to value because of its location. And nothing else compares to it in our area.. then they slap a low ball number on it. Did not use good supporting comps for the home. Instead used one of a home 8 miles away in a neighborhood of less quality. This service is a joke. I would steer clear. I would go with someone who actually knows how to properly assess a homes value. I was literally told my home would be worth whatever someone is willing to pay... this company needs their license revoked.
Edit: since our lowball appraisal.. we waited about 2 and weeks we decided to list our home for sale... we sold it in 3 days.. the contracted price was almost $33k higher than our lowball appraisal from this company! And guess what... it appraised at our price.. and this was within 30 days from this company coming out.
Frequently Asked Questions About McCarthy Real Estate
What services does McCarthy Real Estate offer?
McCarthy Real Estate provides residential and commercial real estate services including home buying, home selling, and real estate appraisals.
Where is McCarthy Real Estate located?
McCarthy Real Estate is located at 318 Second St, Marietta, OH 45750, USA.
What are the business hours of McCarthy Real Estate?
The office is open Monday through Friday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM and closed on Saturdays and Sundays.
How can I contact McCarthy Real Estate?
You can reach McCarthy Real Estate by phone at +1 740-373-1523 or email at info@mariettarealestate.com.
Is McCarthy Real Estate locally owned?
Yes, McCarthy Real Estate is a locally owned and operated company established in 1957.
What payment options does McCarthy Real Estate accept?
They accept payments in cash and by check.
What is the website for McCarthy Real Estate?
Their website is http://mariettarealestate.com.
Are there any insurance agencies near McCarthy Real Estate?
Yes, nearby insurance agencies include Simmons & Simmons Insurance and Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company, which might assist you with insurance needs related to real estate transactions.
What nearby financial services can assist with real estate transactions near McCarthy Real Estate?
Peoples Bank and Perry & Associates offer banking and financial services that might support your real estate financing or accounting needs.
What places of interest are near McCarthy Real Estate for visitors?
Nearby places of interest include Marietta Historic District, St. Luke's Episcopal Church, and Washington County Courthouse — perfect spots to visit before or after your real estate appointment.