Island Club Apartments

3.0
262 reviews
Living Area Image at Island Club Apartments in Columbus, OH
Get DirectionsCallWebsite

Business Details

2225 Montego Blvd, Columbus, OH
43235, United States
(614) 457-8919
https://www.islandclubapts.com
GoogleFacebook

About

Apartment Rental AgencyApartment Building
Come home to Island Club apartments. You can experience the best of both worlds at our gorgeous lakeside community nestled in Northwest Columbus, Ohio. We are located just minutes away from top-tier restaurants, shops, and entertainment attractions our residents can discover. Commuting is a breeze with our close proximity to Interstate 315, so come and find what awaits you at our pet-friendly apartment community.We offer five renovated one and two bedroom apartments for rent that we’re sure you’ll love. Every apartment home comes with amazing amenities such as a balcony or patio, extra storage, walk-in closets, and a washer and dryer in home. Invite friends over and show off your cooking skills in your all-electric kitchen with a breakfast bar and dishwasher. Island Club is the place for you as we keep your needs in mind. Your comfort and convenience are our top priority at Island Club apartments, so the community amenities we offer reflect that. Take advantage of our clubhouse, chill outside by our shimmering swimming pool, or if you prefer a more active lifestyle, utilize our racquetball or tennis courts, or work out in our state-of-the-art fitness center. Our Columbus, Ohio apartments are pet-friendly, and your pets can use our bark park to their heart’s content. Schedule a tour with our lovely management team, or apply for a cozy apartment today

Location

Island Club Apartments
2225 Montego Blvd, Columbus, OH
43235, United States

Hours

Reviews

3.0
262 reviews
5 stars
106
4 stars
27
3 stars
9
2 stars
7
1 star
113

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Communication Issues

Numerous reviews highlighted a lack of clear communication from management regarding payments, maintenance requests, and application processes.

Maintenance Problems

Many customers reported ongoing maintenance issues, including unresolved air conditioning problems and pest infestations, with slow or inadequate responses from the maintenance team.

Management Quality

Feedback indicates dissatisfaction with management professionalism and responsiveness, with several customers describing unhelpful or rude interactions.

Cleanliness and Condition

Several reviews mentioned issues with cleanliness and the overall condition of the apartments, including pest problems and poorly maintained facilities.

Positive Staff Experiences

Despite the negative feedback, some customers praised specific staff members for their helpfulness and responsiveness, indicating that experiences may vary.
  • SA
    sheryl Angeli
    Nov 3, 2025
    1.0
    It was a terrible experience for us when we moved out. I don’t recommend moving to this apartment complex. No clear communications as to where we can pay our last payment when we move-out. We were told to wait for the third-party credit collections for our last payment. We never received any mail. I emailed the leasing office multiple times where to pay the last payment and I got no response. I sent a certified mail with a check for our last payment to Grace and she received it. Until months have past, they forwarded to National Credit Bureau about the unpaid bill and showed Derogatory marks on us. This is unacceptable and unfair for us. We never had encountered any problems with the nice and luxury apartments that I lived before, usually the last payment will be just paid in the leasing office. Totally dissapointing.
  • FM
    Freddy Medina
    Oct 31, 2025
    2.0
    They still haven't done anything about the shower walls since I've been here; they've never been painted and they don't give any answers. Very poor maintenance.
  • JS
    Juliana Schulz
    Oct 7, 2025
    1.0
    My request for the hallway burn light to be replaced has not yet been taken care of. The area is dark.
  • RR
    Ryan
    Oct 6, 2025
    1.0
    Terrible Communication and Unprofessional Management I would strongly caution anyone considering living here. After moving out, I was sent to collections for a final utility bill I was never even informed about. There was no phone call, no email, and nothing mailed to my forwarding address, despite me submitting it properly. When I called and even stopped by the leasing office to get answers, no one could tell me anything. I was told “someone will reach out,” but no one ever did. Their complete lack of communication and accountability is disgraceful. It’s unbelievable that a community would rather damage someone’s credit than take a few minutes to make a phone call or send a simple notice. This experience has been extremely frustrating and disappointing.
  • WM
    Wayne McPeek
    Sep 5, 2025
    5.0
    Nice place. Mia was great. Thanks Mia
Read more reviews on Google

Frequently Asked Questions About Island Club Apartments

What types of apartments are available at Island Club Apartments?

Island Club Apartments offers renovated one and two bedroom apartments for rent with amenities like balconies or patios, extra storage, walk-in closets, and in-home washer and dryer.

Are pets allowed at Island Club Apartments?

Yes, Island Club Apartments is pet-friendly and provides a bark park for your pets to enjoy.