Buffalo Creek Apartments in Indianapolis offers updated one- and two-bedroom homes with modern features like stainless steel appliances, breakfast bars, in-unit washer and dryer, walk-in closets, and private patios or balconies. Set on beautifully landscaped grounds with five scenic lakes, the community boasts a resort-style pool, 24-hour fitness center with a rock-climbing treadwall, sports courts, outdoor lounge with fireplace and grills, clubhouse, and the area’s largest dog park. Located just south of Indianapolis near Greenwood and I-465, Buffalo Creek provides quick access to shopping, dining, and major highways. Professionally managed by The Ardizzone Group, Buffalo Creek combines natural beauty with everyday comfort and responsive service.
Many customers praised the staff for being friendly, helpful, and responsive, particularly highlighting individuals like Cassie and Sam.
Maintenance
Maintenance requests are generally handled quickly and efficiently, with many residents reporting same-day service.
Community Atmosphere
The apartment complex is described as clean, quiet, and well-maintained, contributing to a pleasant living environment.
Security Concerns
Some residents expressed concerns about security, mentioning incidents of theft and inadequate measures like the absence of security cameras.
Mixed Experiences
While many reviews are positive, there are notable complaints regarding communication issues and perceived unfair treatment, particularly related to the application process.
AA
A.
1 day ago
5.0
I have lived in this complex since November 2024 (a little over 14 months) and I am happy to say that living here has been one of the better experiences I've had with apartment living. I did a lease take over for someone, sight unseen (other than some photos/videos) I was leary about moving into an apartment in a city and state I've never been to but the transition was nice and easy. The biggest draw for me to the complex is where it is located. I'm 20 minutes from work and 20ish minutes from uptown area and my sons school...it is in a really nice area surrounded by a housing development where I've felt safe and where my son can safely be out and about. (A few cars drive a little too fast but that's all) When I moved in, maintenance was prompt in addressing any problems. My one complaint that I've consistently had (and I've given up trying to have addressed) is my dishwasher desperately needs to be replaced. All in all though, I'm happy and impressed by my overall experience here. The one property manager Cassie helped me from my first moments here and really helped me make a smooth transition. I felt she really cared and I truly enjoyed every exchange. The biggest shout out I have though is for Lillian or Lilliana? (I'm so sorry if I get your name wrong) She's one of the newer property managers I've met. She's probably the sweetest and kindest young women Ive met during my time here. I needed help making some Christmas magic happen this past December for my son and she stepped up to make the magic happen. I can't say I know of many property managers that would go above and beyond like that...and I've lived in a few apartment complexes over the years. If you are looking for a safe place to live where property staff actually care about you, I cannot suggest a better place than Buffalo Creek. It is very family friendly and peaceful, despite the usual typical apartment complaints.
Cons:
•There are some irresponsible pet owners that don't clean up after their animals, leading to a consistent bad smell.
•Geese everywhere...and you guessed it...goose poop on pathways and typical goose behavior.
•Tow company contracted to the complex is very prompt. I only ever had one scare about getting towed and that was literally the day I arrived and had to park across a few parking spots with truck and trailer. After 15hours on the road, I passed out cold in my apartment and woke to the sounds of trucks outside (if you know, you know)....it was enough to get me running lol but communicating with the property and just being self aware of open vs not open spaces will save you any trouble.
•Warmer months seem to be the busiest for maintenance, expect to wait a little while for low priority fixes. (This was only problematic when my ac kept short circuiting and the heat became intolerable inside)
Pros:
•Family friendly all around.
•Quiet area with very kind and respectful neighbors.
•Prompt service for problems even if there is a little bit of a wait during busier times.
•Kind attentive staff.
•Clean property (trash area can get over crowded at times but trash collects regularly so it's never been a problem)
There really is a lot to be said of this complex but I've definitely said a lot as is. I'll be moving out in March and I pray I find something even slightly as good as I've found here.
Xoxo - The Moens
PP
Pranav Prabhune
Dec 27, 2025
1.0
I was visiting a friend on Christmas day and was there for 3 hours. My car window was broken into and a theft was attempted under a bright street light. There apartment charges so much rent, why do they not have security cameras. While speaking with the residents, I heard that this is a common occurrence. So whoever chooses to live here, please be mindful about your vehicles and security.
TG
Tahni Gilbert
Nov 7, 2025
1.0
So they got my previous post deleted. They broke into my apartment at like 1am without notice because of a draining problem. Which caused a leak for the neighbors below me that had been harassing me, which ended up being something that could have waited until morning as it was a small drip. But yeah let's break into a single 30yr old (at the time) home and start screaming "we are in here" to fix a drip because you don't know how to properly seal systems
AM
Alandra Merriweather
Oct 15, 2025
5.0
Today is my move in day. Lillian ans Christy (hope that's how you spell it😊) have been ao helpful and inviting throughout this whole process. Im looking forward to seeing how these next 12 months play out. Thank you Buffalo Creek Apartments
KK
Kassandraaa.k
Oct 10, 2025
5.0
Love living at Buffalo Creek. Clean and quiet neighborhood. Well upkept! Office staff are very understanding and helpful! Units are modernized and open concept which i love!
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Creek Apartments
What types of apartments are available at Buffalo Creek Apartments?
Buffalo Creek Apartments offers updated one- and two-bedroom homes with modern features like stainless steel appliances, breakfast bars, in-unit washer and dryer, walk-in closets, and private patios or balconies.
What amenities does Buffalo Creek Apartments provide to its residents?
The community features a resort-style pool, 24-hour fitness center with rock-climbing treadwall, sports courts, outdoor lounge with fireplace and grills, clubhouse, and the area’s largest dog park.
Where is Buffalo Creek Apartments located?
Buffalo Creek Apartments is located at 720 Buffalo Run Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46227, United States, just south of Indianapolis near Greenwood and I-465.
What are the office hours for leasing at Buffalo Creek Apartments?
The leasing office is open Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday from 10:00 AM to 6:00 PM, Wednesday from 1:00 PM to 6:00 PM, and closed on Saturdays and Sundays.
How can I contact Buffalo Creek Apartments for leasing information?
You can contact Buffalo Creek Apartments by phone at +1 833-980-3032 or email ava@tag-leasing.com.
Does Buffalo Creek Apartments have an official website?
Yes, the official website is https://www.buffalocreekindianapolis.com/ where you can learn more and explore available homes.
Which nearby schools are close to Buffalo Creek Apartments?
Nearby schools include Suburban Christian School, a private elementary school, and Indiana Baptist College, which offers higher education and religious studies.
What medical services are accessible near Buffalo Creek Apartments?
Nearby medical providers include Dr. Thurman Alvey III for family practice, Austgen Family Dental for dental care, and several sports medicine and physical therapy centers such as Forté Sports Medicine and Orthopedics and Select Physical Therapy.
Are there places of worship near Buffalo Creek Apartments?
Yes, nearby places of worship include Suburban Baptist Church, Shelby Street Pentecostal Lighthouse, and Indiana Baptist College, which also functions as a religious organization.
What shopping or storage options are available near Buffalo Creek Apartments?
Nearby options include County Line Self Storage for storage needs and local businesses for shopping and dining accessible via quick routes from Buffalo Creek Apartments.