Whether you are looking for a house for a family or just one person, we can find the perfect home for you! We can help narrow your search and find a place that you are happy with. As a professional property management company, we will also care for your rental property so that you don't have to!
Customers frequently reported poor communication, including unreturned calls and emails, leading to frustration and feelings of being ignored.
Maintenance Problems
Many reviews highlighted ongoing maintenance issues, with tenants experiencing delays in repairs and inadequate responses to urgent problems.
Application Process
Numerous customers expressed dissatisfaction with the application process, citing issues with application fees, lack of updates, and perceived discrimination.
Mixed Experiences
While some tenants reported positive experiences with responsive management and good service, many others described their experiences as negative, indicating inconsistency in service quality.
Customer Service
Reviews indicated a lack of professionalism and courtesy from staff, with several customers describing rude interactions and unhelpful responses.
KM
Kenya Mickey
Nov 13, 2025
1.0
I gave this landlord money in February March for a house he never got done with he still has 1500 of my money told me he was out of the country he’d send my money back it’s been two months and he has not sent my money or returned a text or call this is the most stressful thing to deal with
RB
Rosa emilia Cinco blandon
Jul 30, 2025
1.0
Muy mala atención y nunca responden el teléfono
JJ
Joseph
Jul 4, 2025
1.0
The negative reviews you read are accurate. This is by far the worst property management company I’ve contacted to date.
The gentleman I spoke to, Garrison, seldom returned my calls. I had to submit multiple online inquiries and leave multiple voicemails just to receive a call 20 minutes from their closing time. This spanned multiple days.
He told me there were 0 qualified tenants for their home in Franklin, IN, and said I would be first on the list if I submitted an application. Evidently this was not the case as I’ve not heard back regarding my application submitted on the 24th except stating that it’s being processed. Crickets, otherwise. They will gladly take your money and do absolutely 0 with it. For reference; credit is excellent, as is income, so should’ve been an easy process, considering the property has remained available for nearly a month.
I’ve received no copy of my background check or any follow-up information regarding whether my application was approved/denied, or even a simple update.
I’d recommend First Key Homes/ Elliott Property Group/ Bullet Property Management. I’m sure there are others, but all of these have been responsive and helpful.
JY
Jill Young
Jun 10, 2025
5.0
I've lived in many neighborhoods with HOAs and management companies and AMG is by FAR the best of all of them. They answer every email in a timely fashion and are very professional and genuinely care about my investment. With any HOA you can't please everyone, it is impossible so you're bound to have some disgruntled people but I can say without a doubt I am thankful our neighborhood is managed by AMG. Our old neighborhood was a disaster because the management company was inexperienced and not effective to the point we were forced to move. Now we have AMG and know we are in good hands! Try them out you won't be disappointed!
JJ
J
Sep 9, 2021
1.0
We applied to a house August 4th. It is now September 7th and we still don’t know if we’ve been approved or denied. I’ve called everyday for weeks asking them to get it going because our lease is up and each time they say we are missing something new. Now they are saying we are missing something, even tho they’ve emailed us back to confirm that they got it. No longer answering calls from my number but will conveniently answer when I call from someone else’s number.
Frequently Asked Questions About AMG Property Management LLC
What services does AMG Property Management LLC offer?
AMG Property Management LLC helps find rental homes and manages rental properties professionally, ensuring both tenants and property owners are satisfied.
Where is AMG Property Management LLC located?
They are located at 6338 N College Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46220, USA.
What are the business hours of AMG Property Management LLC?
The office is open Monday to Thursday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM, and on Fridays from 9:00 AM to 12:00 PM and 1:30 PM to 5:00 PM. It is closed on weekends.
How can I contact AMG Property Management LLC?
You can reach them by phone at +1 317-252-5830, toll-free at +1 888-312-0876, or email at leasing@rentindyhomes.com.
Which payment options are accepted by AMG Property Management LLC?
They accept American Express, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa for payments.
Do I need to make an appointment to visit AMG Property Management LLC?
Yes, appointments are required to visit AMG Property Management LLC.
Can I find rental homes through AMG Property Management LLC's website?
Yes, you can search for rental homes on their website at https://www.rentindyhomes.com/rental-homes/.
What nearby places can I visit when coming to AMG Property Management LLC?
Nearby places include Fresh Thyme Market for groceries, The Coil at Broad Ripple which is a landmark and accommodation, and Kiley Studios if you're interested in event photography.
Is there convenient medical care near AMG Property Management LLC?
Yes, Ascension Medical Group - St. Vincent Broad Ripple Walk-in Care and Forefront Dermatology are nearby for medical services.
What are some nearby services for personal care and beauty around AMG Property Management LLC?
Nearby you can find Kelsey Goudreau Hair, Andrew Hunt Hairstylist, and Salon 6 for hair and beauty services.