First Rate Property Management was started in 1994
by Tony A. Drost, who has been an investor and property manager since 1990. In 2010, Melissa Sharone, MPM® RMP®, joined First Rate Property Management in the Leasing department after graduating from BSU with a degree in Communications. In the following years, Melissa and Tony worked closely to build and improve the company, and in 2017 Melissa’s husband, Jim Sharone, RMP®, joined the company to help takeover daily operations with Melissa. After almost a decade of planning, Tony was ready to phase out of property management, and in 2021 he turned business over to the capable hands of the FRPM team under the leadership of Jim and Melissa Sharone.
Several customers reported delays and issues with maintenance requests, including lack of communication and unresolved problems.
Customer Service
Feedback on customer service is mixed; while some praised staff for being responsive and helpful, others reported rude interactions and poor communication.
Property Management Practices
Many tenants expressed frustration with frequent inspections and lack of notice before entry, leading to feelings of discomfort and invasion of privacy.
Positive Experiences
Despite negative feedback, numerous reviews highlighted positive experiences with specific staff members who provided excellent service and support.
Fees and Charges
Several customers complained about unexpected fees and charges, particularly related to cleaning and maintenance, leading to dissatisfaction with the overall cost transparency.
BB
Bharadwaj Baskaran
3 days ago
5.0
Well taken care of the property and tenants
SD
Skylar Downs
Sep 26, 2025
5.0
It was a bit of a rough start when I moved into my apartment, but the 1st Rate staff has been very responsive and has helped resolve all of the issues I was having!
RR
Ryan
Sep 24, 2025
1.0
Too much to even describe. That's why you see these super long posts. Bottom line, it was a nightmare. I honestly feel pity for anyone that makes the mistake of renting from them.
I could write a book, but I'll just touch on a couple things...
Someone comes onto the property every other month taking pictures. Every 6 months someone comes in to check hvac. Someone comes in for a general inspection once a year. Sprinkler crew every 6 months.
Some of these services are needed, but what is so traumatizing is that they slap a paper on your door the night before saying they're coming the next day. After a quick knock, they let themselves in. You wake up and someone is in your house. No notice for sprinkler crew. You just see them in your backyard. When you move, they'll bring over prospective tenants to tour your home.
I never felt like I had peaceful enjoyment of the property and would often wake up wondering if someone was in the home. They sent a notice to all tenants saying that if you change the locks they will drill them to come in and then bill you.
To Owner:
Thank you for the response. In regards to the property owners, I often wondered how maintenance was handled. Some repairs seemed overpriced compared to what I know they should cost, which left me wondering whether owners are billed at cost, or is there an additional markup?
KT
Kristie Terhaar
Sep 24, 2025
5.0
Ashley and Daniela were very helpful in this process. I had a great experience this time renting.
TC
Tabby Catt
Aug 26, 2025
1.0
We've had nothing but problem with this company since move in. They had to resign 3 times cause they did numbers wrong. They signed us for an unfinished unit. They charge for every maintenance request.
Frequently Asked Questions About 1st Rate Property Management
What services does 1st Rate Property Management offer?
1st Rate Property Management offers property management and real estate agency services.
Where is 1st Rate Property Management located?
It is located at 1251 N. Cole, Boise, ID 83704, USA.
What are the regular business hours of 1st Rate Property Management?
Monday through Thursday, they are open from 11:00 AM to 1:00 PM and 2:00 PM to 5:00 PM. They are closed on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, with Friday open by appointment only.
Does 1st Rate Property Management require appointments?
Appointments are not required to visit 1st Rate Property Management.
Does 1st Rate Property Management provide onsite services?
You can call them at +1 208-321-1900 or visit their website at https://www.boiseproperty.management/.
Can I follow 1st Rate Property Management on social media?
Yes, they are on TikTok at https://www.tiktok.com/@firstratepm, Instagram under @firstratepm, and Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/131349173578731.
What nearby places can I visit before or after visiting 1st Rate Property Management?
Nearby you can visit Panache Hair Studio & Day Spa for massage therapy, Idaho Pinball Museum for arcade and museum experiences, and Boise Racquet and Swim Club for sports and gym activities.
Are there health and medical services near 1st Rate Property Management?
Yes, nearby health services include Cole Dental Boise, Dr. Michelle Hitch DDS, and Treasure Valley Holistic Care.
What other professional services are located near 1st Rate Property Management?
Nearby professional services include Impact Directories (advertising and public relations), Denison's Publishing Inc. (marketing and advertising), and Everything Sleep Consulting (professional services).