McGraw Property Management & Leasing - Arkansas

Reviews

• AM

  Ariel McGolden

  Feb 20, 2026
  1.0
  Pretty disappointed with my families experience with this realty company. Our realtor, Madison, was not much help… My husband knows people who had bought homes from this company so we wanted to give it a shot. my husband and I were the ones who found multiple properties that we were interested in and sent them to her. So we basically did the work. We were only able to view two homes with Madison out of the many we sent. The first time we went down to the Fort Smith area to view homes, we viewed two homes, she was late to the first one and had to contact the second home DURING our viewing. She also didn’t give us much info about either of the properties while touring. I feel like you should have everything set before your clients show up… she never sent over homes to us to see if we were interested in those and when we started running out of options… she didn’t have any available. Pretty lazy and unmotivated if you ask me…She also never worked with our schedule, when we wanted to tour homes but it was on her time, not ours which isn’t very helpful. We really wanted to view a home and were ready to make a deal since she was never available to tour homes with us (so we didn’t want to miss this opportunity) and she said she spoke with the contact for this home. “There’s currently no offers..” etc. now the home is pending so AGAIN! We missed a great opportunity. The lack of timing and professionalism really needs to be worked on. I hope this realty has more professional realtors working here.
• DM

  Daniel Maechler

  Feb 18, 2026
  5.0
  Having Tiffany T. as our realtor was probably the best decision when it comes to our recent home buying process. She helped every step of the way and did so much for us. If you need a real estate agent Tiffany is the absolute best.
• GM

  Grayson Moore

  Dec 17, 2025
  5.0
  I very much enjoyed my time with McGraw realtors I could not think of a bad thing to say about any of them. I stayed in one of there properties for 4 years straight and it was great. They are very reasonable and super easy to get ahold of. Which is not common with some landlords. Anytime I had a problem they had it fixed before I was home and would go out of there way to make sure that there tenants where taking care of. I have referred several friends/co workers to use McGraw property’s they are easily one of the most reliable and and efficient relator companies to rent from!!!
• DM

  Doyle McHaffie

  Dec 17, 2025
  5.0
  7401 Martin Drive is a high end duplex complex with lots of amenities, great overhead lighting, and lots of room for activities throughout the duplex. Gone are the days of cooking in a galley kitchen as this kitchen contains an amazing 5 burner stove, with so much space even I could lay down flat without touching anything. Moving on to the bedrooms they are even better, the master bedroom contains a walk in closet with ample space for clothes and for storage, additionally it contains a master bathroom with lots of cabinet space. Moving onto the second bedroom, it contains an enclosed closet that is nice and spacious and can hold plenty of clothes, knick knacks and paddy wacks! The best part of this space is by far the living room however, with an open concept you can cook, clean, study, AND sleep all while in your living room. I certainly recommend this place if you are planning to move out for the first time, or if you’re moving to a new space. Allison Gibson additionally was very friendly and got us moved and settled in an amazing timeframe, we were moved in within a week of applying, getting approved and paying the deposit. Thank you for being a wonderful realtor group.
• CC

  Carly

  Dec 17, 2025
  1.0
  In our experience, we regret moving here and do not recommend renting through McGraw based on our experience working with Allison Gibson. While the property appears newly remodeled, the quality of work and overall management have been disappointing. Over the past several months, we have dealt with ongoing issues related to poor communication and unresolved maintenance, including multiple missed repair appointments that required us to take time off work. Maintenance requests often go unaddressed unless they are emergencies, and issues present at move-in, including a bathtub that has not drained properly since day one, have still not been resolved nearly three months later. Because of how unprofessional this experience has been for us, we have seriously considered breaking our lease. This may work for some tenants, but for us it has not been worth it, and others should proceed with caution. Nine of them even bother to respond to negative reviews. Only positive. Because they don’t care if tenants are getting screwed and break the lease because of their poor management. She does not care about quality work, but how much money she can guzzle up without informing people.

Frequently Asked Questions About McGraw Property Management & Leasing - Arkansas