RF
ragdad falderbalgen
Mar 17, 2026
Edit: Message to Petco - You already had the chance to resolve this issue through the proper channels. Customer support, and store employees chose to ignore me and make me feel as if I don’t care for my pets. As I said, you have lost my business permanently.
I normally don’t leave reviews, but this one bothered me enough that I think people should know, especially parents buying fish for their kids.
I’ve gone to petco forever, since I was a child. For this reason I chose to purchase two guppies from the Spanish Fork Petco on February 21. I actually put time into doing it right. I tested their water, saw there was a big difference in hardness compared to mine (25dGH down to 9dGH), and drip acclimated the fish for about an hour and a half so they wouldn’t get shocked. By the next morning one of them was already struggling at the top of the tank (20 gallons), I immediately tested parameters and they were fine (10dgh, 9dkh, 8.0ph, 0 nitrites, 0 nitrates, 0 ammonia). By that evening it was dead. Parameters still good. My other guppies, completely fine. All of my shrimp in the same tank are also fine
Feb 24th I brought the fish and a water sample back, expecting the 30-day guarantee to cover it. Instead I was told my alkalinity was “too high” and that “tanks are hard.” They tested it at around 161 ppm KH, which is about 9 dKH. I did my research before setting up my tank—9 dKH is actually within Petco’s own recommended range of 8–12 dKH (at the lower end, might I add). My pH was 8.0 and stable. Nothing extreme. Let me point out that their store water being 25 dGH IS extreme.
I figured maybe it was just a miscommunication, so I contacted corporate. They replied at first and asked for all the details, which I provided. They didn’t respond for a week until I asked for a follow up (March 3rd). They replied and said my water was “significantly outside of the recommended balance” but didn’t explain how. They also claimed I never bought the fish at all, because THEY checked the wrong member account. I corrected that and asked a simple question: what exact standard are you using to deny this if my water is within your own guidelines? Since that email, It’s been over two weeks now (March 17th). They have not responded to me.
Petco talks a lot about health, wellness, and supporting people who care for their pets. That’s honestly part of why I felt comfortable buying fish there in the first place. But this experience didn’t line up with that at all. When a guarantee is denied without a clear explanation, and then communication just stops, it’s hard to build any trust back. I have cats, dogs, and multiple fish and shrimp tanks. I don’t plan on stopping there. Petco has lost my loyal, and local business permanently.